Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET — Page 11

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#251

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

I know this won't happen, but I feel like the only thing that could save the show at this point is if Oak makes a statement saying he appreciates Mandy's support but that he doesn't want to see the show close over this and that he has his blessing to come in and play the part.

again, that won't happen and would take an incredible gesture from Oak, but it might work

#252

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

dramamama611 said: "BroadwayBaby -- how do you know he didn't ask his friend to stop? Just because he didn't do it publicly doesn't mean he didn't do it. (and I realize he might NOT have, but I admit: I dont know, therefore I will not assume.)



Skimble -- wait, so sticking up for someone isn't necessary when its an unknown/non-famous person? Ridiculous -- those people need support MORE.



I understand why it was done, the true only unreasonable part is the people thinking they are righting a wrong. It wasn't a wrong, it was unfortunate.




"

I don't know if he did or didn't ask those tweets to be taken down, but by not saying anything after they all came out he implicitly agreed with the meaning behind them.

#253

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

It is a business, a difficult one, but when you lost your job in this business it is different than a computer programmer who presumably can then apply for hundreds of possible openings.

The producers handled this (and a lot about this show) poorly.

The situation is multi-faceted and people are viewing it through their own lenses of what matters most to them ... diversity, fairness, ticket sales, celebrity, et al. That leads to vastly different interpretations of the same event (some clouded by confirmation bias), few of which tell the whole story. As the Quakers say, "Everyone holds a piece of the truth."

We do not learn from each other here (if that is of any interest) if we merely hop on and keep advocating our own position repeatedly. Learning requires balancing sharing our own take with genuine interest in and inquiring as to why others might see this differently from us.

Erivo (and anyone else for that matter) does not need to change being who she is on social media to conform to others’ expectations. She speaks her truth and that can have both positive and negative consequences.

Updated On: 7/29/17 at 07:24 AM

#254

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

I went to sleep so worried last night that I'd wake up to a closing notice...

Anyway, I thought of a really bad joke last night during my Comet-induced insomnia, and I'll put it here to add a tiny drop of sunshine to this storm.

What did Ethel Merman, Tyne Daly, Patti LuPone, and Bernadette Peters say when the audience is walking out of their star vehicle?

Goddbye, my Gypsy lovers.

Hardy har har

#255

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

Except he DID make a statement, (not that it addressed the tweets). https://www.broadwayworld.com/article/Okieriete-Oak-Onaodowan-Opens-Up-About-GREAT-COMET-Exit-I-Will-Not-Be-Returning-20170728



(But I do see your point.)


If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it? These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
#256

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

J*s*s Chr*st.

"Nobodies" have been replaced by "big names" for as long as showbusiness exists.

Why is this suddenly turning into a zoo?

Is Oak not a normal human being? Is he entitled to be treated differently in some way?

#257

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

"The show’s producers and creative team were clearly blindsided by the turn of events. They had previously asked another performer, Brittain Ashford, to take a leave during the summer so she could be replaced by a well-known singer-songwriter, Ingrid Michaelson, and did not anticipate that replacing Mr. Onaodowan with Mr. Patinkin would be seen differently.

“So sorry to have missed the racial optics of it,” the show’s creator, Dave Malloy said on Twitter Friday. “We had to do same thing with dear beloved Brittain so in my head it was no different.”

The question is, why should black people be seen differently and not be treated like everyone else?

There is a HUGE list of nobodies being replaced by stars. That's been going on for decades and decades.

Everyone who brings race into this is racist.

Updated On: 7/29/17 at 08:17 AM

#259

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

Jordan Catalano said: "The show signed its own closing notice by replacing the star who was keeping it open with someone who nobody knows, hoping just the fact he touched Hamilton was enough to get people to spend money on him. It's truly one of the stupidest casting decisions I've ever seen.



"

Agreed. Where was their common sense?

#260

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

Haterobics, that's because I use the same attitude against racial separation as some others do in favor of it. That keeps it in balance.

I pray to god that someday people will see Oak as an actual human. Who can get fired too. Just like any other human. And who has the right to feel frustrated. Just like Stephanie J. Block when she was replaced by Menzel in Wicked.

But to bring race into this and actually apologize for firing a black person/replacing him when a month earlier literally the same thing happened with 2 white people is lunacy. Not everything is about race. This is a good example of that. The racists make it about race.

Updated On: 7/29/17 at 08:33 AM

#261

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

I'd think after this hoopla it will be very hard for Oak to find another job on Broadway in a leading role as producers may worry his name won't sell tickets and that if they try to replace him with a non-black actor before his contract ends, a similar incident may happen. Sort of like an unofficial blacklist.

#262

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

MadonnaMusical said: "Jordan Catalano said: "The show signed its own closing notice by replacing the star who was keeping it open with someone who nobody knows, hoping just the fact he touched Hamilton was enough to get people to spend money on him. It's truly one of the stupidest casting decisions I've ever seen.



"

Agreed. Where was their common sense?




"

Seeing some of the race reactions on twitter and some people clearly see race only, and love to live by that idea, maybe the casting directors gave him the role/it helped him getting the role/were influenced by peer pressure over time, because of his color?

Now that's what he should be pissed about. That he may have gotten the role for the wrong reasons. Not the fact that big names mean better business. Because if you don't understand that, you should not be in showbusiness. From what I've heard he was nothing more than just "ok" in the role, acting wise and singing wise. Didn't really connect. And he clearly wasn't ready in time.

Who will ever hire someone who is entitled to not be able to get fired? This day is a black day in the history in mankind. The race gap grows bigger and bigger. Thanks Oak and Cynthia and consortes.

Updated On: 7/29/17 at 08:42 AM

#264

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

JBC3 said: "Since great opportunities for actors of color are usually more limited, of course race is going to be one lens through which people view this situation. Doing so is not racist."



The statistics say otherwise. The percentage of people of color on Broadway shows versus the percentage of the population is actually much bigger, as shown in another thread. There seem to be a lot of opportunities for people of color, more then for caucasians percentage wise.

With that said, choosing to see a case of someone being fired for reasons cleary aside from race, as a race thing is racist. Those people should really evaluate why they feel the need to pull race into this and why they think it will help not treating someone as human. This false entitlement will ruin society.


Updated On: 7/29/17 at 09:09 AM

#265

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

Dave28282 said The statistics say otherwise. The percentage of people of color in Broadway shows versus the percentage of the population is actually much bigger, as shown in another thread. There seem to be a lot of opportunities for people of color, more then for caucasians percentage wise.

With that said, choosing to see a case of someone being fired for reasons cleary aside from race, as a race thing is racist.




1. I am not sure this is the relevant percentage as it does not address what % of available roles on Broadway are available/going to actors of color? The general population is not the landscape being discussed.

2. I intentionally specified great opportunities, of which actors of color themselves are saying are harder for the to come by.

And if someone only sees this situation through the lens of race that is indeed a limiting perspective, but it does not in any way meet the definition of racism ... prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed against someone of a different race based on the belief that one's own race is superior.






#266

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

It definitely is prejudice and entitlement. And also discrimination, because what's happening is "making a distinction in favor of a person based on the group, class, or category to which the person is perceived to belong rather than on individual attributes".

Racism is discrimination and prejudice towards people based on their race or ethnicity, so it is exactly that.

Updated On: 7/29/17 at 09:21 AM

#267

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

This is a thoughtful perspective from an All that Chat commenter.

I had thought they had escaped unscathed from their mishandling of Oak's arrival, but now I think that staying mum on the delay - as well as the delay itself - hurt them with public perception and is fueling the sentiment against them.

And it's not hard to see why this has rubbed many people the wrong way.

Viewed through a certain lens, they set Oak up for a spectacular failure when they marketed him as a star (while failing completely to do the advance PR work to make him a star), and then ensured that failure by compromising his entrance into the show,
and then very suddenly - and publicly - terminating his appearance in the show, bringing in his complete opposite to take over the part.

I can see why this became a dramatic story. I can see why many people view this as another example of how white America makes it difficult for Black men and to succeed in traditionally white realms. I'm sure it wasn't the Kagans' intention to moonlight Oak, but that was the result.

And they're still doing it. In their latest apology, they continue to put the blame on Oak, rather than themselves. They're sorry that Oak took all this the wrong way, rather than anything they did.

This is like a year ago, when many people saw Scott Rudin putting the blame on the pregnant lady for shutting down "Shuffle Along", but with larger repercussions.

I do have a lot of respect for Dave Malloy. He very quickly took the responsibility on himself, which must have been very hard to do.

Ultimately, two great artists find themselves humbled, and Rachel Chavkin and her company are watching their show turn into the very thing they built it to act against. This is the kind of producing that is damaging to the art and the artists, and I'm sure both Oak and Dave are thinking of all of the warning signs they ignored on their way to this public embarrassment. (At least Dave got his show on Broadway for 9 months.)

#269

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

JBC3 said: " Viewed through a certain lens, they set Oak up for a spectacular failure when they marketed him as a star (while failing completely to do the advance PR work to make him a star), and then ensured that failure by compromising his entrance into the show, and then very suddenly - and publicly - terminating his appearance in the show, bringing in his complete opposite to take over the part."

I agree, giving him the part was the mistake. The producers realize this now too. They should not have to apologize to anyone except Oak, because he's the one out of work. The only thing they should have done is make a statement which said that unfortunately they made a mistake by casting him, he turned out to be not meeting their expectations, and that's it. Their apologies to anyone racist who feels betrayed is lunacy. They should be above that.


" I can see why this became a dramatic story. I can see why many people view this as another example of how white America makes it difficult for Black men and to succeed in traditionally white realms. I'm sure it wasn't the Kagans' intention to moonlight Oak, but that was the result."

I can see that too, seeing how crazy some people are but this should not be the producer's business. They should be above that.


" I do have a lot of respect for Dave Malloy. He very quickly took the responsibility on himself, which must have been very hard to do."

By doing what? Saying that the show's action is racist because they are not content with Oak? That really is a lame duck reaction. He would only get my respect if he would acknowledge that is sucks for oak, but that the show is above that discussion.

#270

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

I love Cynthia Erivo, but she's a bit out of control on Twitter.


A Chorus Line revival played its final Broadway performance on August 17, 2008. The tour played its final performance on August 21, 2011. A new non-equity tour started in October 2012 played its final performance on March 23, 2013. Another non-equity tour launched on January 20, 2018. The tour ended its US run in Kansas City and then toured throughout Japan August & September 2018.
#271

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

Some remarks:

Producer: “As part of our sincere efforts to keep ‘Comet’ running for the benefit of its cast, creative team, crew, investors and everyone else involved, we arranged for Mandy Patinkin to play Pierre."

Cool, nobody benefits from a closed show.



"Mr. Malloy also said that the show made the cast changes out of financial necessity.

“The show was in desperate shape; sales after Ingrid leaving Aug. 13 were catastrophically low,” he said on Twitter. “Show would have closed.”

So the show was in desperate shape and would have closed. Is there anyone who thinks Oak's ego is more important than 100 people being out of work?



Producer: "Oak, who was scheduled to appear as Pierre for this period graciously agreed to make room for Mandy, and we sincerely hope that Oak will return to us in the fall or winter. He is a terrific Pierre."

It appeared Oak wasn't so gracious and did not really care for the benefit of the show, because if he would stay in it, there would be no show. Mandy could save his job. And this is also a very nice thing to say of the producers but it's business too.

Updated On: 7/29/17 at 10:17 AM

#272

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

Let me get this straight.. Mandy Patinkin, who is 64 years old, is supposed to play a role previously played by a 35 year old(Groban) and a 29 year old(Oak). why does this remind me of Joan Crawford stepping in to play Christina's part in a daytime soap?

#273

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

It's sad to see how such a great show just got... thrown away. By the tw*tter teenagers and the producers. Really hope they find their footing soon, but by the way it's looking- it won't make it.

#274

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

schubox said: "I know this won't happen, but I feel like the only thing that could save the show at this point is if Oak makes a statement saying he appreciates Mandy's support but that he doesn't want to see the show close over this and that he has his blessing to come in and play the part.

again, that won't happen and would take an incredible gesture from Oak, but it might work




"

I'd like this to happen, but I think the whole situation would look rather comical in a "you're welcome --- oh no, YOU're welcome" way. And the big gesture of Mandy withdrawing from the role will turn into nothing if he changes his mind. I hope I make sense. But once again... I would LOVE something to suddenly save Great Comet.

Except for Hugh Jackman. No Hugh Jackman, please BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

#275

BREAKING: Mandy Patinkin Withdraws from THE GREAT COMET

Dave28282 said: "Some other facts:

Producer: “As part of our sincere efforts to keep ‘Comet’ running for the benefit of its cast, creative team, crew, investors and everyone else involved, we arranged for Mandy Patinkin to play Pierre."

Cool, nobody benefits from a closed show.



"Mr. Malloy also said that the show made the cast changes out of financial necessity.

“The show was in desperate shape; sales after Ingrid leaving Aug. 13 were catastrophically low,” he said on Twitter. “Show would have closed.”

So the show was in desperate shape and would have closed. Is there anyone who thinks Oak's ego is more important than 100 people being out of work?



Producer: "Oak, who was scheduled to appear as Pierre for this period graciously agreed to make room for Mandy, and we sincerely hope that Oak will return to us in the fall or winter. He is a terrific Pierre."

It appeared Oak wasn't so gracious and did not really care for the benefit of the show, because if he would stay in it, there would be no show after Mandy would have left. And this is also a very nice thing to say of the producers but it's business too.





"

These are not "other" facts...they've been well established throughout this thread.

And yes, Green Waver, that's the case and he would have (likely) been wonderful. This, too, has also been covered in the original announcement thread.


If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it? These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $67