Nicticorax said: "I'm genuinely confused about the intense skepticism towards Blankenbuehler. Is the issue just that he's primarily a choreographer so people are questioning his directing ability, or did he direct something awful that I'm unaware of? For me, Spider Woman is such a dance-heavy show that it makes sense to have a director/choreographer. Obviously I'd like it to be well directed, but I also feel like the book is strong enough that it will shine through with a good cast."
I don't know if this was the last musical directed by the great Hal Prince, but it certainly was his last "successful" show. And he did some marvelous things with it, at times it was top notch musical comedy fare, sometimes campy melodrama, sometimes Felliniesque; these daring and differing tones mixed and matched perfectly. I'm guessing we worry that without a visionary director this might just be a lesser version of a difficult piece.