After Eight said: "Jarethan wrote:. "Her competition was laughable."
"Laughable????" That's the word you use to dismiss actresses like Estelle Parsons, Charlotte Rae, and Brenda Vaccaro, all of whom gave wonderful performances?
"Laughable," you say?
I really don't think you covered yourself in glory inany aspect ofyour post."
Brenda Vaccaro, who I always loved, had a supporting role in a terrible play that ran for 8 performances. Her role required her to shout a lot, as I remember. In an even remotely decent year, she would never have been nominated.
Estelle Parsons, who I have admired since I became aware of her in Bonnie and Clyde, was TERRIBLE in the Seven Descents of Myrtle, one of the most reviled plays Tennessee Williams ever wrote. She overacted in the extreme. The play ran 3 1/2 weeks; I remember being amazed that it ran that long, given how brutal the reviews were.
Charlotte Rae was enjoyable in an ensemble performance in a show that ran 6 1/2 weeks. In an even remotely decent year, she would never have been nominated...maybe in the supporting category.
I imagine you are quoting something that I am not recalling when you refer to my not covering myself in glory. I guess if you are consistently obnoxious, unless rhapsodically praising work from 50 years ago (whether brilliant or thoroughly mediocre), one will at least be remembered -- as a crank.