So I saw the show the other day. I enjoyed it, but I still have major problems with the music and lyrics. It's an important story to be told, but I'm still not convinced that this was the medium in which to tell it. I find the direction a little odd and I found that the use of such a small cast to play so many characters causes a bit of confusion and lack of character depth. For many characters, I would find myself understanding them and caring for them just as they were swept away. Also, the acting can be a bit much at some moments (lots of "musical theatre acting"
. The music is energetic, but isn't particularly tuneful or complex and some of the lyrics are very clunky. I don't know why but I found myself reminded of The Last Ship, but just a bit more optimistic in tone. I liked the set quite a bit and Jenn Colella has a gorgeous voice. The cast is wonderful and seems to be having a wonderful time. The show is lively, hopeful, and joyous. It wasn't my cup of tea, but I'm sure it will have a good life and I'm sure it will be very present at this year's Tonys.