I saw it last Sunday and thought it was pretty disappointing. Sure O'Hara and James CAN sing and if you are here for that then this is a treat. However, there are many choices about the show that are simply buffling. First, the large ensemble except the girl is basically living props and they basically do not get to sing AT ALL iirc. I'm happy that they have a job to pay the bills but it does feel like a waste of resources. Also, O'Hara's powerhouse singing is way too powerful even for the barn of studio 54, to a point that in some of the later songs you don't feel that alchoholism erodes her at all, and for this reason the "redemption song" towards the end feels like it comes out of nowhere. To be honest, I think the show can do without 50% of the songs and put more focus on developing the characters especially in the first thirty-ish minutes, because as it is now the characters begin spiraling before the audience gets to know them enough to care. The highlight for me, though, was the motel scene, which I desperately wanted more of because how much more it did to establish the characters in both the book scene and song than the rest of the show combined.