I was at last night's preview and was ready to reassess my feelings after being somewhat underwhelmed at Second Stage. I admit that I liked it more this time around, but I still wasn't completely won over. There were a few cosmetic changes to the lyrics and book, but essentially it's the same show that we saw off-Broadway. They have now made it very clear what really happened when Evan broke his arm, but other things I took issue with weren't changed. I think it still gives off a Next to Normal vibe, but it stood on it's own more for me on second viewing.
I didn't mind the projections of social media posts off-Broadway, but I wish they would have built more of a set for the transfer. They've added more screens, but they serve to distract rather than enhance.
I still wish Jennifer Laura Thompson had a song of her own. I still wish they opened up the show with a solo for Ben Platt. I still don't love Evan's two classmates or the ending, but obviously this is the show the creators are happy with and I really don't expect it to change at all during previews.
The two things the show really has going for it are the cast and the intriguing premise/plot progressions. The melodies are often very catchy too; the lyrics aren't always as strong as the music, but certainly rise above those in A Bronx Tale-esque fare.
I have a question for those who have followed this show more closely than I have: Has Platt or the creative team ever explicitly stated what condition Evan suffers from? One of my friends last night, who hadn't seen the show off-Broadway, was convinced at intermission that Evan had Asperger Syndrome. It's an understandable assumption give his inability to connect socially, his dislike of being touched and Platt's general mannerisms. After the second act he was he felt they changed course and simply made him a kid suffering from social anxiety. I think this is a flaw in the writing and quite frankly in Platt's performance, which is otherwise very strong. If he is on all these meds, wouldn't he be more numb than manic as he acts in the first half of act one? Maybe they're trying to remain ambiguous with what's medically going on with Evan, but I think they should be a little clearer.
This is making me sound like I didn't like the show at all, which isn't true. I do think there's a lot of good stuff there and I'll be making a return trip for sure. I guess I'm harsher on this show because I think it has so much more potential than your average workman like Broadway musical and I just don't think it reached its full potential yet.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!