Tonight was a real treat. Having seen this production twice now with both Groban and Ashford, it was so fascinating to see two new performers take the stage.
Nicholas Christopher is a killer Sweeney (no pun intended). He evokes the menacing presence that was lacking with Groban. His “Epiphany” stopped the show cold. Jeanna De Waal’s Mrs. Lovett is much more subdued and controlled than Ashford’s Lovett. De Waal is less broad with the comedy, but is still very funny. She just doesn’t do as much mugging as Ashford did. Her voice is absolutely stunning.
The both had great chemistry and played well off each other. I would akin tonight’s performance to the experience I had seeing Donna Murphy go on for Bette in Hello, Dolly!… There’s still a great, albeit different, energy in the audience. You still get a solid production of a great show, just without the huge “star wattage”. In a way, this is refreshing. While it’s always fun to see big stars on Broadway, sometimes the show itself takes a backseat to the lead star.
I still have my plethora of issues with this production ranging from the borderline nonexistent direction to the bizarre choreography and finally to the abysmal sound design. However, it’s one of Sondheim’s greatest, so even an imperfect production is still enjoyable.
Anyways, all in all, a great night of theatre. Super glad I got the chance to see both of these insanely talented performers take the stage together!
"There’s nothing quite like the power and the passion of Broadway music. "