Saw HAMILTON last night. All I can say is WOW. Yes, it was almost 3 hours long and I would like it to be 15 minutes shorter but I can’t imagine what could be cut - every song and scene builds character and story. In order to understand all the personal and political events in the life of Alexander Hamilton, the musical, as now stands, gives you a pretty comprehensive and understandable view of some pretty complicated historical events. To cut much would lessen the impact of the historical story. I guess a tiny trim here or there... but I never once flagged in my attention. If anything, I want the CD issued soon so I can delve into the plot and character more.
Some of the intricate rap scenes were so clever in word play that they zoomed by, with much audience reaction, and then zoomed on to something even more clever. Who could remember this lightning paced wordplay?
I also might say that the “anti-rap” comments made by people who have not seen the show... well, they should see it and judge for themselves. My audience last night was a healthy mix but I know there was a benefit that evening for some really wealthy East Side types - the ones you would think would cringe at rap. But they stood at a moments notice at the end. Immediately. Cheering. I guess they realized the rap and the modern take and the history was something they really liked. It certainly isn’t a dry historical take. And, as others point out, it’s not JUST rap - it’s some gorgeous and moving songs. My husband said at intermission that, theatrically, it invents a whole new language.
As for moving to Broadway, I say GO. And I wouldn’t mind it this season. I think it would slaughter any other competition including FUN HOME. Yes, it needs that trim and tightening but it is really a fantastic piece as is.
I do think I would be hard pressed to nominate people from the show - I mean WHO WOULD I LEAVE OUT!!??? Lin-Manuel Miranda - well, he’s just fantastic and the fact that it’s all his own words. YIKES! Supporting players for nominations? Leslie Odom, Jr. (Actually he would probably be a lead); Renee Elise Goldsberry (brilliant); Brian D’Arcy James (more brilliant - although it’s only 3 short scenes with one continuing song) and is he leaving for SOMETHING’S ROTTEN? I almost wish he would stay with HAMILTON because he is so great - but perhaps a lead in a Broadway musical would appeal more to him! My personal favorite of the evening was Daveed Diggs as Lafayette and Jefferson. If I voted for the Tonys, he would be the box I would check. Just astounding in his command of the stage, humor and movement.
Beforehand, I worried that I thought I would be falling asleep during it. It was a long workday, then dinner at a party reception with drinks. But from the first scene to the last, I was hooked. Special commendation for the gorgeous set that works so well with the piece, the lighting and Andy B’s perfect choreography and movement.
This is the best thing (musical wise) I’ve seen all season... maybe in a few seasons.
Updated On: 2/6/15 at 11:38 AM