#51
Posted: 5/4/09 at 10:16am
I remember seeing this show with my father. We were both quite pleasantly surprised with it and the ship at the end of Act I was quite effective. I remember the gasp from the audience as the tableau was revealed an there were no "aw"s or laughter, just silence. The starry sky meeting the glassy water to create the horizon perspective was quite brilliant. From where we sat, it looked great, but I guess people wanted a larger representation or something. I'm not sure there would have been anything that would have pleased everyone, just as is the case with every show.
I think it is one of the best Broadway scores in the last 20 years and the ensemble was the best I've heard in any Broadway show. The musical direction and the orchestrations were perfection. Even when the entire cast was singing, you could understand every last syllable and the subtle nuances in the musical direction (some of which do not appear in the Broadway cast recording, but do in the Dutch recording) enhanced the score greatly.
Unfortunately, since the film was released soon after the musical opened, the public was over saturated with all things Titanic and I think the general public probably believed they were somehow connected and I do agree that a stage version of the film would have been much more ridiculous. I always thought it was a shame the film couldn't have fallen more in line with the musical rather than focusing on a silly fictional love affair that happens to take place aboard the Titanic rather than featuring the numerous fascinating true stories that already existed on the ship.
I think it is one of the best Broadway scores in the last 20 years and the ensemble was the best I've heard in any Broadway show. The musical direction and the orchestrations were perfection. Even when the entire cast was singing, you could understand every last syllable and the subtle nuances in the musical direction (some of which do not appear in the Broadway cast recording, but do in the Dutch recording) enhanced the score greatly.
Unfortunately, since the film was released soon after the musical opened, the public was over saturated with all things Titanic and I think the general public probably believed they were somehow connected and I do agree that a stage version of the film would have been much more ridiculous. I always thought it was a shame the film couldn't have fallen more in line with the musical rather than focusing on a silly fictional love affair that happens to take place aboard the Titanic rather than featuring the numerous fascinating true stories that already existed on the ship.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
