Posted: 3/27/17 at 4:07pm
Valentina3 said: "GavestonPS said: " Yeah, they could have looked up the rules on the internet, but who does that except you and I?"
*you and me
since you guys are both being petty
"
Sorry, val, but you are wrong. "You" and "I" in the sentence in question are both SUBJECT pronouns: "You do that"; "I do that"; your clue might have been the use of "who", also a subject pronoun.
You are confusing my phrase with instances of OBJECT pronouns. To wit, "She has invited you and me." She invited you. She invited me. She invited us.
I is always the subject of a sentence or clause; the subject indicates who does something such as "look up rules on the internet".
Me is always the object in a sentence or clause; the object indicates one to whom something--"invited"--is done.
As long as we're being petty. I trust you realized the point of my original post was that grammar is no longer taught in American schools, so the claim that "everyone" should know the basic rules is unfair as well as unrealistic. I wasn't jumping on the grammar-correction train until you pulled me aboard.
Grammar v. spelling: since the instances at issue here involve issues such as possessive form v. contractions, I think the rules can be considered either.
Updated On: 3/27/17 at 04:07 PM