schubox said: "I just got out and have pretty mixed feelings. Parts of it were overwhelming in the best way possible. Groban (when he was actually in it) was wonderful.
Some of the sections really drag. And the characters aren't nearly enough to earn some of the emotion they're trying to generate at the end.
But all that being said, I had an amazing time. The highs are so high, it's like nothing else I've ever seen.
The staging and lighting are phenomenal
I agree. I attended the matinee today so I'm still thinking it through, so reading comments on the Message Board is helping me along.
I didn't see this in its other incarnations so it had to stand on its own as a Broadway musical. While I see what they're trying to do it's not a journey I'm interested in much at all. I've read "War and Peace" a couple of times and immediately realized the profound Pierre & Natasha plot in Tolstoy's novel was little represented in the musical. Had it been about unrequited love as one sees in the final two scenes here then it would have the dramatic hook that I could attach to as an audience member
Josh Groban is woefully underused. I get it; that's the way it's written. I'm not a groupie-fan of Groban's; I admire his voice and his discipline with it. Turns out he's giving an actor's performance here that I admired and was moved by. He lumbers like the "corpulent" Pierre, shuffles like a lost soul, and doesn't play any of it for pity. He's the only one in the show whom I felt for and about, and that's the role of Pierre. He plays against type, and that's bold and interesting. The reader's heart is moved by Pierre in the novel. Without this role the musical would have traveled like water off a duck's back, in my assessment.
Again, this is my opinion and taste and that's subjective. At the end I felt as assaulted as I did after seeing "Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson" because it's bombastic, visually loud like Baz Luhrmann's "Moulin Rouge" and night-clubby shallow.
Perhaps "Once" and "Hamilton" have spoiled me for musicals. I attend to be told a story through story and music that will bring me to another place by curtain calls. I felt nothing except when Groban sang.
Though she's doing everything right as she's being directed, Denee Benton comes across more as a sweet Disney heroine than a Russian countess who's prevented by her social status to follow her heart. Instead, she follows her hormones which gives the musical its plot at the price of what could have been elegance and empathy.
Updated On: 10/31/16 at 08:08 PM