ColorTheHours048 said: "I saw it on Thursday night and completely adored it. I similarly didn’t miss any of the material they cut, because the movie does an excellent job of zeroing in on Matilda herself. As a lifelong fan of the novel, the original movie, and the musical, I think this adaptation gets the most right of each of the others. In particular, it makes the most sense of the link between Matilda and Miss Honey (largely due to Alisha Weir and Lashana Lynch’s tremendously effective performances). I even loved the new final song “Still Holding My Hand”. I always thought it was strange the show ends on a prolonged book scene after “Revolting Children” and the new song ties up Matilda and Miss Honey’s story gorgeously.
Speaking of Alisha Weir, nominate this kid for an Oscar. What a performance. Such a transparent, vulnerable performance from such a young actor. She’ll break your heart. The abuse and neglect Matilda endures is more obvious here than any other iteration of the story - it’s clearer than ever that the character’s brilliance and supernatural abilities are the product of her trauma - and her performance channels all of this is one of the most genuine child performances I’ve ever seen.
I thought Emma Thompson was great and makes her Trunchbull unique enough to escape the shadow Pam Ferris and Bertie Carvel cast over the role. She’s by far the most frightening iteration, often looking like a mix between The Child-Catcher and Christopher Walken’s Headless Horseman, but she doesn’t have as much of the comedic edge I’d prefer to make her just a little more fun. However, the movie chooses to ground itself more in reality than the musical did, with Matilda’s imagination offering the necessary flights of fancy, so I understand toning down the character’s more obvious strangeness.
I’m sad I won’t be able to own this on Blu-Ray. I would happily add it to my collection. But I’ll be seeing this in theaters one more time and will definitely watch… far too often on Netflix."
Came on here to give my assessment but you pretty much summed it up. I thought the film was smart, strong, and well paced. The way they rearranged the Acrobat/Escapologist stories was clever (these were sections in the play that lived or died by the ability of the actress playing Matilda) and the pay off during “My House” was heart wrenching. Weir was sensational, such an emotionally intelligence performance and perhaps the first time I heard and understood all the lyrics in “Quiet.” I, too, wished Thompson had been slightly funnier (Christopher Seiber has that quality of making nearly everything funny, so perhaps an unfair comparison), but she had some real great moments, her crazed depression in her final scene was really fun.
I love this show so much (I saw it 5 times) so maybe my assessment will never be super fair but I really loved it and it’s a nice companion piece to the show.