Vintage, I think you quoted me saying it was differently and unusually sung (it is!), but that necessarily mean that “unusual” will translate to “bad.” They just don’t sing it in R&H style.
The actors are good singers, but it’s like if Beverly Sills had been hired to sing Wagner. Well, she’s not a Wagnerian singer and her Brünnhilde would have be no Brigit Nilsson. It’s not that Sills couldn’t sing the notes, but her voice type and style is not what one typically associates with the role. Still, if she were forced to do it, at the very least she would have given an intelligent interpretation of the role.
Going to Oklahoma, you would expect someone to sing Laurey the way Kelli O’Hara would. Long, legato lines and a round, warm tone that fills the room. That is the usual. Rebecca Naomi Jones does not do this, nor does anyone else in the cast. This is the unusual approach. The Beverly Sills sings Wagner approach.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!