Wow.
Saw the performance today and still trying to collect myself. I absolutely loved this production from top to bottom. I imagine it helps that I don’t have that much of a relationship with the material. I’ve been a fan but never loved it the way I love some other R&H shows. Fish and his team have done wonders without changing the text.
I can see why this has been so disive. I loved how Rebecca Naomi Jones sang the score - from belting all of “Many a New Day” to the soft falsetto of the “People Will Say” reprise, but it’s jarring for anyone married to the standard interpretations. I thought her performance set-up the dream ballet perfectly. To be completely honest, some of what was presented in the ballet was lost on me, but what I got was a stirring examination of Laurey and her sexuality. It works completely with the point of view the production has on Jud, and their version of Laurey/Jud relationship.
Ali Stroker owns every second she is onstage - I fully expect her to be nominated. Mary Testa too. The way she is directed to play the final scene was terrifying (in the best way).
Patrick Vaill’s Jud is endlessly fascinating. I never expected to cry during “Pore Jud”, but I did.
I hope to see this again before it closes. It’s not for everyone but it’s one of the best productions I’ve seen in years. This proves why we need more flexible spaces on Broadway. I couldn’t believe this was the same theatre where I saw ONCE ON THIS ISLAND a year ago.
"Oh look at the time, three more intelligent plays just closed and THE ADDAMS FAMILY made another million dollars" -Jackie Hoffman, Broadway.com Audience Awards