Toby could be a Tony-nominated or even Tony-winning role, is probably the best role outside the two leads and “Not While I’m Around” is one of the few songs from the score that people seem to enjoy out of context, which means it could have a more lasting memory/social media impact and wider reach. In addition to potential pay, commercial longevity, Sondheim prestige, and a new range of hot high-profile industry network contacts right now I think he made the right choice.
Give me claws and a hunch, just away from this bunch.