JasonC3 said: "I know what I am about to suggest is like comparing apples and oranges, or maybe apples and potatoes, but the contrast in comments about Anderson and Feldstein do make me chuckle.
Beanie would kill for the discretion Anderson is getting: she can't really sing, she can't really dance, but she'll get a bit better, and OMG, its Pamela Anderson!
And yes, I know the roles a very different and Chicago has long brought in people for reasons other than their singing and dancing abilities. It is just that reading both threads is quite the contrast."
Definitely apples and oranges. Chicago has been proven to work as a show and still be quite fun if the Roxie isn’t necessarily a Broadway caliber singer or dancer. The text even suggests she’s not that good. Whereas Funny Girl’s plot hinges on Fanny being extremely talented and she has to deliver, like, 90% of the score. And they’re all songs that are much more difficult than anything Roxie sings.