Listened to the cast album, watched a few promotional performances on YouTube...this show (IMO) is awful and I do not understand the hype at all.
The cast album and the promotional performances are nothing like the experience of the full show live. Not even close. I mean, most musicals aren't, but this one especially. The cast recording is just a studio version of the numbers and there have been some changes (some of which significantly change the impact of the number) and don't include most of the dialogue. The songs are indeed catchy, which is why there were fans of the recording without having seen the show, but that's not really what the hype is about. The dialogue, the performances (of the Chicago cast), the lighting, the choreography, the concert atmosphere, the audience energy...all of these elements create an electrifying cohesion that is extremely effective. THAT'S what the hype is actually all about. I initially had little interest in the show and ended up seeing it the first time because I have season tickets to the Shakespeare Theatre in Chicago and it was included as a replacement for the halted premiere of Bedknobs & Broomsticks. Six is not awful. Far from it.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian