SweetLips22 said: "I am only judging from brief clips and photos but in all of them Hugh is grinning like a cheshire? cat and giving a performance like 'gee but it's good to be here' . Shipoopi? looks as interesting as a hall dance night.
Hugh would have been brilliant in the movie Chicago and even guest appearances in it on Broadway but nah!, not for HH the way he seem to be playing him. I would like someone a little more shop worn and knocked around by life on the road. There would have been a 'Marian' in every town for him but something about her breaks through to find that softness that resides in all of us no matter how we try to hide it. Whether that arc is there I do not know but that's how I would like to see my HH."
To each his own 
However, someone on the other theatre "chat" board unearthed documented old character notes on Marian ( which indicated she was the the child of the old man who bequeathed the library to her) and also notes on the character of Harold Hill.
Six pages on the Hill notes --
https://songbook.historyit.com/detail-page.php?id=2302
On Page six of the Hill notes --
https://api.historyit.com/iiif/2/5ae8f072695922.51531174/59c288522ab139.34492925.jpg/full/!5000,5000/0/default.jpg
"Spellbinder? Oh yes indeed. Look at Hal Hill as he is in 1913. 35 years old, 5'11" - 160 lbs., hazel eyes -
warm and deep, brown hair, rangy, straight, well-postured,
good-looking, lean, normally tidy, exceedingly well-proportioned
Pleasant, interested, generously cheerful to anyone and everyone.
Hal Hill, metropolite, carnivalian, lyceumist, tab artist,
vaudevillian - and recently out of his deeply-buried frustrations,
he has begun to add an almost hypnotic quality to the reactions
he is able to invoke from the spirit-hungry
small town middle-westerners
. They don't know that
his magic depends largely on their own open-eyed
wonder, under which spell he can make them accept almost any suggestion he
offers. And they also don't know that there wouldn't be any
magic at all if it wasn't for the red silk lining of his cost ..."
This could have been the basis of the new Zaks/Jackman interpretation of the character ? Hugh Jackman is a consummate actor with great range - it is doubtful that he would have simply acted out the role on a whim?
Updated On: 12/30/21 at 10:25 PM