I saw the show last night, and thought it was fine, not terrible, not great. It has a lot of elements that are working for it. David Hyde Pierce is excellent (he was the main selling point for me anyway) and the cast was well committed.
When the show dealt with broader emotional topics like music, spirituality, and romance/connection, the material worked best. However, the immigration aspect of the story (which is most of the piece) was definitely schlocky, preachy, and one note, only scratching the surface of these issues without ever teaching us anything new or really ever going anywhere interesting.
Some of the songs were solid and well delivered, but many of them, again, suffered from surface level depiction of events and ideas. The white savior problem with the show exists, however it didn’t personally bother me as much as others. Walter is an interesting enough character, and I was fine that he was the lead.
The audience seemed to somewhat enjoy it, there was laughter and polite (if not quite rapturous) applause in some moments. Again, I overall felt this show was just okay. It has some elements that do work really well and others that simply fall flat. I do not think this show is terrible, and it is a relatively engaging night at the theatre. If you’re a fan of anyone involved on the creative team or of any of the actors (particularly David Hyde Pierce), check it out. I was on the fence, and I’m overall glad I saw it.