Unpopular Opinions You Hold — Page 12

I love Wait, too!
I enjoyed the ST film as a film, but not as a musical. The singing sucked.
I think ITH would be better without the rapping.
I'd MUCH rather see Shrek and 9 to 5 than Billy and N2N.
I love everything about POTO and Mendes' Gypsy.

I know why it's wonderful on an intellectual level, but, for the most part, SITPWG leaves me emotionally cold.

I think Sutton Foster should have played Clara in The Light in the Piazza at some point. It would have been a great role for her!!! She can be goofy and show off that wonderful voice!

I would choose the Sweeney Todd Revival over the original production any day. I also prefer the phantom pies.

Marissa Jaret Winokur deserved her Tony and although her voice is not the best, her acting is spot on!

I think the Ballad of Sweeney Todd could have EASILY been worked into the movie version and HBC's voice is paper thin, though I love her look.

I did not like Billy Elliot one bit.

The only thing I did not enjoy about the Little Shop of Horrors revival was the large and final Audrey 2 puppet. The mouth barely opened when it talked and it totally took away from his fierce appearance.

Last: Hunter Foster and Matthew Broderick are just, well, awful!

I was gutted that Sydney Carton, a character I've idolized for half my life, was played by James Barbour. Now that he's recording the role, I'm gutted all over again.

Sorry, fans, but that's my story and I'm sticking to it.

^ Whoa...someone needs to lighten up.

This isn't a thread where anywhere needs to defend anything. Obviously MCfan2 realizes his opinion in not the majority -- THUS THE REASON it is posted here.

I'm sure YOU are getting more upset that Mr. Barbour would over any of these comments.


My more recent unpopular opinions:
--ITH was only "ok"
--With my 2nd viewing of Billy Elliot, I am not all that impressed
--I don't mind Alice Ripley's singing at all, & I think it fits the score beautifully. (I also have never heard here sing flat.)
--While I do not miss Jonathan Groff from the cast of Hair, there is one thing I think he portrayed in a better light than does Creel (whom I adore in the role, sans this one thing.)
--I still think Curtains was absolute CRAP and DHP did not deserve that Tony award.

--and my favorite unpopular opinion -- I think everyone is entitled to discuss their opinions, even when it is not in agreement with mine.
--

---

I loved The Little Mermaid!
I think Les Miz is one of the best shows.
This isn't so much an unpopular opinion as an unpopular show, but one of my favorite recordings is Frankenstein, starring Hunter Foster.
and lala09, I completely agree about "Solla Sollew," I love Seussical!

I think Spring Awakening has one of the most intelligent scores I've ever heard, and I feel that the music can be deconstruced and highly examined just as much as any Sondheim score. (The lyrics are still terrible, though).

---

claudioislove, simply judging by the photos I've seen of Groff, Creel is SO much better looking as him. Not that I'm saying he's OMGHOT! as him, but I'm saying that the wig better suits Creel.
WickedRocks, Company does work FAR better than Sweeney Todd ever thought about. Sweeney, in my opinion, needs multiple sets and just needs to be bigger in general. Company can work with a table and some chairs, Sweeney, I don't think, can. If that revival of Company had toured, which I think it should, I would totally have seen it, or tried to at least.
So I guess I'm adding this to my list:
I HATE the most recent revival of Sweeney Todd, the one starring Patti Lupone.

I really do not like Patti LuPone's voice.
I also am not a fan of In the Heights.
I also don't mind the Little Mermaid >.>

---

I saw "Hair" today and was quite disappointed. The cast was excellent, even with Will Swenson out (Steel Burkhardt took his place and was very good). They are all very talented, energetic and likeable. But there was no plot. It just dragged and dragged from one dance sequence to another. I've heard so many good things about it and my expectations were quite high, but I walked out disappointed. My husband also thought it was a "waste of a good talent". We must be the only 2 people to actually dislike the show and I am feeling quite guilty about it :)

"^ Whoa...someone needs to lighten up."
Perhaps it is you who might want to lighten up...? My comment for MCfan2 was a DEBATE to her expression of "gutted", which, as a logical first impression, sounds like she was implying that his interpretation of the role would be atrocious, or at the least, a mismatched performance. I believe I was respectful enough to MCfan2, and even posed a question for her opinion. It was up to her to respond, and she did, making clear that she was not referring to his performance. End of story.
Why would MCfan2 need a defensor? I don't get it. I was not "attacking" her, just stating the obvious (without mentioning I forgot to add that Barbour received 3 nominations for this role).
Actually, I beg to differ about MCfan2's opinion being in the minority..."when" did it become popular to even name Barbour in any thread, let alone praise him? I have yet to read a thread about Tale or Barbour, where at least 2 or more posters don't say nasty or ironically bashing things about him. Or, that doesn't get deleted.
Let's not "assume" that these comments are passing lightly by Mr. Barbour, either. How could they, really? He's just in a position where it is hard for him to address these, where I can exercise my right to speak up, as an observer. If anybody needs a defensor, it's him.

"...I think everyone is entitled to discuss their opinions, even when it is not in agreement with mine."
Well, then, try not to get upset if I voice mine, especially when I was not even addressing you :{

I guess this is my unpopular opinion (according to Dramamama611): If I lighten up anymore, I'd float in air

Updated On: 7/13/09 at 03:18 AM

"This isn't a thread where anywhere needs to defend anything. Obviously MCfan2 realizes his opinion in not the majority -- THUS THE REASON it is posted here."

Well said, dramamama

Another from me. Elaine Stritch? Kinda horrible. Screechy horrible. I hope she sounded better when she was younger.

---

I hold so many unpopular opinions.

-I don't like Sutton Foster, at all.
-I think Adam Pascal and Anthony Rapp need to GTFO from RENT and although I am a RENThead, I refuse to see the final tour because frankly I've seen better Marks and Rogers.
-I don't like: Shrek, Mamma Mia!, Phantom of the Opera, Evita, Little Women, Aida, Billy Elliot, Rock of Ages OR Gyspy
-I like 13, Legally Blonde, Cats and RENT (I know Cliche and Tweenish of me...but don't worry I like a bunch of obscure stuff too)
-I think Patti LuPone needs to me slapped and told STFU
-Think Christian Borle NOT John Gallagher Jr. should of won the Supporting Actor in a Musical Award at the Tonys in 2007
-I think Disney can stop making musicals anytime now.
-I like The Battery's Down.