magictodo123 said: "I’m really sad at how people are reacting to this. Yes, Sara is a performer. Yes, she has acted. But when it comes to Waitress she is first and foremost a member of the creative team. I’m sure they considered many different options before they landed on McPhee."
So the rumour is apparently that Sara and Gavin Creel are doing a limited run as Jenna and Dr P in London at the end of Jan (for maybe 6 weeks)! I assume this is to give the show a financial boost and keep it going in the west end . If this turns out to be true it now makes sense to me why Sara won’t also be closing the show in NYC as I doubt shed want to commit to doing both. On that basis I think Kat was always probably their top choice to close the show in nyc if Sara or a new person wasn’t going to (and assuming they asked Jessie and she didn’t want to). She’s a great Jenna imo (and was even better in London), she’s played Jenna for 8/9 months now so knows it like the back of her hand and she won’t need much rehearsal time, she’ll be pretty much performing with the same cast she performed with last year (Drew, Natasha, Christopher and Caitlin!), she’s reliable and she also did v well for the show commercially. So yeah makes total sense to me.