I’ve seen about 60 shows on Broadway, which is far more than most people I know in real life. It’s nothing compared to some people here, though. How do some manage to see everything, on both sides of the Atlantic? I am green with envy.
To make me feel better about myself, please share any shows or performances that you failed to get to? Who DIDN’T see Patti in Gypsy, or Bette in Hello Dolly, or Nicole in Sunset etc. etc.?
Thank you…
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/2/15
I missed gypsy with Patti. And Aaron in Catch Me If You can. Angela Lansbury in Night Music.
"Bobbi Boland", and I'm sad every day about it.
Understudy Joined: 4/30/14
The Falsettos revival, The Bridges of Madison County, Hunchback of Notre Dame, and Murder Ballad. I still kick myself every time I listen to the cast recordings.
Chorus Member Joined: 7/30/21
I still occasionally kick myself for missing the 2018 revival Three Tall Women.
I was kicking myself most of this year for missing Dead Outlaw, but thankfully I'll have my chance in a few months.
Broadway Star Joined: 8/7/10
I'm dating myself a bit, but my greatest theatrical regret has always been missing the Broadway production of Nicholas Nickleby in 1981. (I saw the version filmed for PBS, but it's obviously not the same.). More recently, I was most sorry to miss The Inheritance, for which I had tickets in late March 2020 (though I did see a great production at the Geffen in LA) and William Jackson Harper's performance in Primary Trust.
Moose Murders
Legends
Bobby Boland
Patti in Sunset Boulevard
Featured Actor Joined: 9/25/22
Anything Goes was one I should have checked out, but I didn't think it was a must-see. My mistake.
Sunset Boulevard in the 90s would have been great.
Thoroughly Modern Millie.
War Paint.
And definitely the Hello Dolly revival.
In recent memory, I really wish I had seen Shuffle Along. I also regret not seeing John Cameron Mitchell in the Hedwig revival; by then I had already seen it a couple of times and I couldn't fit in another return visit.
Not Broadway, but I still intensely regret not attending the 24 hour performance of Taylor Mac’s 24 Decade History of Popular Music. I saw the entire piece about 1.5 times, in the 3 hour chunks and then two 12 hour performances in Philly, but that one time only 24 performance is legendary.
Broadway Legend Joined: 2/10/11
Since I stopped living in the New York area):
Going way, way back to when I lived in or around NYC. There really are not a lot. I saw most everything that i wanted to see.
I am only counting shows I missed since living in NYC: Spring Awakening OBC, American Psycho, and Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet. Would also kill to have seen Tonya Pinkins in Caroline, or Change.
Stand-by Joined: 7/17/19
I'm dating myself, but I saw my first Broadway show in January 1974 on a high school field trip - Pippin. Living in northern NJ, I've been coming into the City ever since - almost 650 shows later. Some of the shows I'm sorry to have missed:
Da
The original production of Sweeney Todd
The original production of Nine
Nicholas Nickleby
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof (Kathleen Turner revival)
Angels in America (parts 1 and 2)
Three Tall Women (off-Broadway at the Promenade)
The Inheritance
Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? (with Laurie Metcalf - had tix for April 2020)
Appropriate - (I had tickets and missed it twice - once because of a snow storm and the second time because my car broke down).
Stand-by Joined: 4/4/17
jagman106 said: "I'm dating myself, but I saw my first Broadway show in January 1974 on a high school field trip - Pippin. Living in northern NJ, I've been coming into the City ever since - almost 650 shows later. Some of the shows I'm sorry to have missed:
Da
The original production of Sweeney Todd
The original production of Nine
Nicholas Nickleby
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof (Kathleen Turner revival)
Angels in America (parts 1 and 2)
Three Tall Women (off-Broadway at the Promenade)
The Inheritance
Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?(with Laurie Metcalf - had tix for April 2020)
Appropriate - (I had tickets and missed it twice - once because of a snow storm and the second time because my car broke down)."
I am in the same time frame as you and saw most those that you missed, except Woolf and I had tickets to it in late March 2020 and Cat…Tin Roof. I will say that “Da” was one of my worst nights in the theater. I should have left..but kept thinking with Bernard Hughes, this has got to get better. It never did and the thick Irish accents made it difficult to understand and follow.
What I really wish I had seen was Nathan Lane in “Forum” I still don’t know how I did not.
Stand-by Joined: 7/17/19
BentleyB, thanks for your perspective on Da. Perhaps I'm thinking it was something more special. I remember seeing The Beauty Queen of Leenane in the late 90s and the Irish brogue was so thick, I couldn't understand what anyone on stage was saying for the first 10 minutes, but I had no problem for the rest of the show.
One show I forgot to add was Othello with JEJ and Christopher Plummer. I was in college and grad school in the late 70s/early 80s, so I missed a lot during those years.
I caught Nathan in ....Forum. It was a pleasant evening in the theater, but if you missed it, I would say you should really have no regrets.
Blanchett in Streetcar at BAM. Had a ticket, fell asleep, and missed the performance.
Metcalf in Virginia Woolf. I too had tickets to see it in April 2020. I truly hope that performance has a second life.
Jagman, you could always try the movie version of Da. Barnard Hughes reprises his Tony-winning role, and Martin Sheen doesn’t even attempt an Irish accent as the son!
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/26/19
I think often about missing The Inheritance and I regret it up to this day. I definitely could think more about shows that I wish I've never seen.
Stand-by Joined: 10/8/18
I turned down last minute comp tickets to see Natasha Richardson and Alan Cumming in Cabaret because I was too busy at work. I didn’t get around to seeing that production until its return engagement and then with Michelle Williams who I love but not in that.
And Cromer’s Our Town especially given the mixed feelings I have about the current production.
Taboo, American Psycho, The Man From Oz
If only I were a few years older I would've loved to have seen the original productions of Arcadia, The Who's TOMMY, Kiss of the Spider Woman, the '92 Guys and Dolls revival, Cherry Jones in The Heiress, and Ralph Fiennes in Hamlet.
There are a few shows off the top of my head that I regret not seeing when I could've: the Dillane/Ehle The Real Thing, LaChiusa's The Wild Party, Marin Mazzie in The King and I, Thou Shalt Not (I am deeply jealous of all the knowing tugboat jokes), Dance of the Vampires, Lestat, and I surprisingly never made it to The Pillowman or Jerusalem.
Sometimes I'm behind the curve and start to appreciate a performer at a later date. I wish I saw Santino Fontana in more when he was a regular on and off Broadway.
Jordan Catalano said: ""Bobbi Boland", and I'm sad every day about it."
Same here. I had tickets for the play’s second week of previews and it closed on me. I did get to pop into the Cort Theatre when they were loading the sets out. The marquee and photos outside the theatre were still up. Still bummed I never got to see what would have been Farrah Fawcett’s Broadway debut.
Videos