If I were to include tryouts:
The Czar of Rock and Roll
The Civil War
Sweet Smell of Success
The Addams Family
Big Fish
The Last Ship
And in the West End:
Closer to Heaven
Love Never Dies
Peggy Sue Got Married
Grease (revival)
Boy Band
Stand-by Joined: 5/29/11
On Broadway: First Date. Off Broadway: Atomic
I've been pretty lucky to not see any truly terrible shows, but;
Oklahoma! (Patrick Wilson revival) many great performances, just dreadfully long
Bullets Over Broadway. Beautiful to look at but not engaging at all
The worst show I ever saw was Copacabana. It was a tour with Franc D'Ambrosio who was so miscast. I wanted Rico to shoot Lola instead.
And as giggle worthy as Thou Shalt Not was -- you had to admit that you saw Norbert Leo Butz just shine through the show and become a star.
Understudy Joined: 4/5/13
Woman in White (projections gave me vertigo)
Saturday Night Fever
Glory Days
Leap of Faith
Spiderman: Turn Off the Dark
If/Then (the only time I've wanted to leave at intermission, didn't do so, and regretted not doing so)
Wonderland
Broadway Star Joined: 9/23/11
"Title Of Show" Should have been re-titled "Me, Me, Me".
Chicago at the Pantages in Hollywood.
Christy Brinkley has no place within 100 feet of a Broadway stage. She couldn't sing, dance or speak and it appeared she could barely walk. They did a terrible disservice to hear by allowing her to get on stage.
Understudy Joined: 6/5/14
Spiderman: Turn Off the Dark and the national tours of Porgy and Bess and American Idiot.
And Hot Feet! I forgot about that mess. (I called it "Hot Mess". YUCK.)
I absolutely hated Chicago so much that I left during intermission. The music and movie were great, but the Broadway production is so boring. I also hated Spider-Man. I disliked (but didn't think were horrible) Bullets over Broadway and If/Then.
Sister Act
Evita (revival)
and the horrific Bare "revisal" at New World Stages
Musicals: A Little Night Music (2010 Revival), Motown, and Hands on a Hardbody
Plays: Enron and The Big Knife
Motown. Without any question or hesitation. (Followed a VERY close second by Times They Are A Changin').
I even found Soul Doctor, First Date, Dance of the Vampires and Prymate more redemptive than that dreck that is stinking up the Lunt-Fontanne.
The only thing I've ever seen on Broadway that I truly couldn't find a redeeming quality in was the revival of Jekyll & Hyde, which is so unfortunate because I love the score based on the Warlow recording.
The Realistic Joneses comes in close second. Both were TDF tickets, and I still felt ripped off.
I've seen some stinkers in my time living in NYC. Urban Cowboy and Lestat come straight to mind. However only one show has ever had the honor to put me to sleep. I say "honor" because I'm an insomniac who regularly needs medication to go to sleep. In fact, typing this now I've been awake for two and a half days. That show was The Lion King.
Hands On A Hardbody
Holler If Ya Hear Me
Wonderland
Good Vibrations
Leap of Faith (tryout)
Brooklyn - had a couple good songs, but otherwise a hot mess
If/then is the worst thing I've ever seen on broadway...sooo bad
broadway
Via Galactica
Spider-Man
West end.
Peggy sue got married
Saturday night fever
Tour
I really disliked Mary Poppins
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/12/05
I've seen some rough national tours: Ghost, Catch Me If You Can, Camelot with Lou Diamond Phillips. The worst was seeing Chicago earlier this year with Paige Davis and John O'Hurley. If it were not for the fact that I paid $20 student tickets, I would have asked for a refund.
Swing Joined: 9/22/13
I saw the pre-Broadway tryout of My One and Only in Boston. It was not ready to be seen by a paying audience, or any audience for that matter. It was like the actor's nightmare in which the actors don't know anything about the show they're in. But they went on anyway. Two weeks later it was a big hit in New York.
Videos