Jordan Catalano said: "Well, I’m excited for anew ALW musical!Sure his last show left a lot to be desired and was a tabloid mess, but he’s one of the last true old school musical theater writers we have and he’s written some brilliant things. After “Bad Cinderella”, maybe he has something to prove?"
I think he still has good tunes in him. The big problem is his micro-management style, where he is the main auteur of his shows and he hasn't worked with great directors on his past few new musicals. I've made this comp before, but it greatly resembles the post-Hammerstein era of Richard Rodgers' output.
There's no question that BAD CINDERELLA would have been a much better show if he let Emerald Fennell do her thing with the book and if it had a stronger musical comedy director/choreographer with an authorial hand like Jerry Mitchell or Casey Nicholaw or Sam Pinkleton or Luke Sheppard. (plus solving the leading lady problem.)
I hope the recent trend of letting people like Ivo and Jamie Lloyd and the CATS guys revive his shows could lead to some bigger swings with his next new musicals.
Or write an actual opera. I'd like to hear it. Any opera house would commission him, and in opera the composer is king.