I've been posting here for 22 years, and this is one of the saddest threads I've read. Can't help but think of other star vacations when a replacement was a gimmick that added a jolt. I'm old enough to have seen Raquel Welch fill in for Bacall when she took her vacation from Woman of the Year. This wasn't the multi-month post-Bacall Welch run, which was notoriously successful. This was a 2 week long-slotted Bacall absence, December 1-15, 1981 - something she had not done during Applause - and the choice of her replacement shocked Broadway (and Bacall, infamously insulted).
I was there the first night, thanks to the TKTS downtown booth, in the second row of the orchestra at the Palace. The vibe in the house was "oh boy! Get ready!" Palpable as lights dimmed for the overture. It was a (pre-internet) crowd clearly expecting an utter debacle. And of course, Welch brought her own unexpected magic, limited though it may have been, that served a mediocre vehicle like Woman of the Year. And the audience went effing crazy. We didn't hate watch, we had a helluva good time. The NY Post, a rag that loathed Bacall's politics, splashed the first Welch performance curtain call on - wait for it - the front page. Seriously. Splashed is appropriate, because the show ends with Tess having water dumped over her head - and the famous Welch figure. Even in a Norma Kamali terry robe, quite a photo. Something like "What a woman!" I'm guessing that producers have since always hoped for that to happen. It seldom does.
For Gypsy, they would've been wise to do a shutdown or simply allow the well-received standby to do the week, since this gifted performer doesn't generate box office. And that aspect is what is so sad. The gifted Ms. Montego deserves better than to be set up to fail so publicly..
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling
Updated On: 7/2/25 at 09:26 PM