First time posting, hi all! I was there tonight, and it was....I mean hey, it was a dress rehearsal. What all do you really expect? Flawless performances? No mistakes? There were mistakes, there were issues, but there is also some interesting potential.
I'm such a JCM fan, and whether Darren was good or not didn't even cross my mind until midway through Wig in a Box, because I was so bizarrely devastated that he wasn't JCM. It felt like I was watching a tribute concert to Lena and JCM with Rebecca (though I think she's great) and Darren as Yitzhak/Hedwig. I really wanted to love him, but I also really wanted to hate him because he isn't JCM. That isn't fair to Darren as a performer, but it is what it is.
I think he could make something of the role, but he's not there yet. He did have flashes of real, true excellence - his Tommy Speck is really great. He gives a lot to the Tommy lines in the scene right before The Long Grift in a way that is different than NPH, Andrew, Michael, or even JCM. It's odd to see the show now with no crate, he's back in the car again, etc.
I'm sure I'll suss out better thoughts once I get my head around it, and once I see it NOT as a dress rehearsal. I was just there on Sunday and man, I already really, really miss JCM. I feel for anyone who has to fill his tremendous, talented, heartrending shoes.