I saw this today (last show of my trip!), and was surprised at how much I enjoyed it. While there is definitely some work to be done, there are plenty of really great things happening on that stage. The performances are great, especially Carmen Cusack who gets to sing the two best songs in the score - the title number and "How?'. The score is very lullaby-esque for the most part - it has a wistful, dreamy, and floating sound and feel that works well. The design elements are STUNNING. The vast stage of the Beaumont is bathed in gorgeous lighting and projections, and the set has some mammoth pieces that are just beautiful.
While I really enjoyed this, there is no question that the second act needs to be trimmed down. I think they could easily achieve this by cutting the godawful Sophia Loren sequence and the penis rocket ship song. That whole segment just took me out of the moment, and went on way too long.
I was sitting in row E of the 500s (LincTix), and the view was perfect. I always think it is exciting to have a completely new and original musical on Broadway. While Flying Over Sunset does need some tightening, I still found so many things to enjoy, and I am so happy I saw it.
"There’s nothing quite like the power and the passion of Broadway music. "