I was there this evening. The show is beautiful and by and large exquisitely performed... but ultimately not particularly engaging, which is not how I felt at NYTW, where I found the show very moving.
I was also shocked by how many obvious fans of the show were there- I saw at least two girls dressed as Persephone in the audience, and overheard quite a few conversations parsing the differences between incarnations of the show.
The changes to the score seem to me to have padded it out... and this is already an extremely thin story. The second act drags far too much for how little ground needs to be covered. This could have been a slamdunk 90 minute one-act.
There is also the issue of the reconception of Orpheus here, as some kind of savant. But Orpheus just becomes the least compelling character, and one that it is very hard to see anyone falling madly in love with- or putting up with at all. He is easily the least developed of the four principal roles. Hades wants power, Persephone wants freedom, Eurydice wants to survive, and Orpheus... wants to write a song? That’s all we know until he loses Eurydice. And part of this is Carney’s performance; Damon Duanno and the NYTW take on Orpheus was to make him a charismatic rebel, complete with a James Dean red jacket. But this take on the character is far different- the show on multiple occasions hints he is “touched,” and Reeve Carney loads up the character with tics that scream “I am an actor playing a autistic character!” But ultimately he ends up a blank. Which is a problem.
The show takes it for granted that we know Eurydice and Orpheus will fall in love, and lets that do the heavy lifting. Which COULD work... but then the show’s attention shifts from Eurydice in the first half to Orpheus in the sedond, and it is a much shakier foundation. They feel like the B couple to the far more interesting Hades and Persephone, who Patrick Page and Amber Grey make vivid and rich with unspoken history and character.
The singing and music is spectacular, and Chavkin comes up with so many gorgeous, haunting moments of staging, so I can’t say it’s not worthwhile, or that the journey isn’t worth it. But ultimately, I feel like the show wouldn’t be there when If you turned around.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."