I was there this afternoon, and while Hadestown isn’t a perfect show, it feels like a breath of fresh air this season compared to the other new musical offerings. Finally a new musical that serves up some creativity and craft. Rachel Chavkin, I love you.
Hadestown has been cast in the Fun Home/Passing Strange/Band’s Visit/Great Comet role this season. It’s the artsy show with a little brains, a little talent- with an emphasize on the latter. Still, despite those comparisons, it’s Marie Christine as my theatergoing friend pointed out that this might most closely resemble. Both are updated tellings of Greek literature and both had a slight coldness that keep your emotions at a bit of a distance. It’s hard to get weepy for Orpheus and Eurydice the same way you might about Alison attempting to talk with her father or Stew working through the regret of turning a cold shoulder to his mother during her hour of need.
There is also a slight Subways are for Sleeping syndrome here too, in that the supporting couple is more interesting than the leads, and any emotions I felt where skewed toward them. Amber Gray is such a wonder. A truly unique talent, and in this cookie cutter world I appreciate her all the more. I love her drunk/strung out take on Persephone. It contains shades of Judy Garland and Billie Holiday at the end of their ropes and her voice is very refreshing. Likewise, it’s hard to imagine anyone other than Page playing Hades.
André de Shields is where it’s at, though. Old school Broadway talent, proud and regal. A real showman. Brilliance. I hope I’m that cool when I’m 73.
Eva and Reeve both sound great, but they have the weakest parts. Still, I enjoyed them and think they did what they could.
The score is catchy as hell and the orchestrations are really sublime. Chavkin and her creative team really work wonders in transferring this from the round to the proscenium stage. The set and lighting are A+.
I wish I felt that final push to say I really, really loved it, but I really, really liked it ain’t that bad either!
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!