""Jane2 mentioned that a woman has played Hedwig before.
I can't recall who. I'm thinking Ally Sheedy, but that can't be right....
Anyway, a famous actress has played the role before so it can be done.
ETA: It was Ally Sheedy, Off-Broadway."
It was Ally Sheedy. I never saw her but heard she was terrible. "
I saw Ally Sheedy play Hedwig at Jane Street. Horrible. Dull. Never once did I think I was seeing a man with a botched sex change on stage. I believe she was the last Hedwig to play before it announced the closing and then JCM came back for one week of performances to close the show officially.