Overall I felt the show was enjoyable, live musical theater in prime time is always a good thing.
Carrie Underwood seemed to get more comfortable as the night went on, although her acting was occasionally non-existant. Stephen Moyer, on the other hand seemed to be struggling to act with his natural accent, he isn't that stiff on True Blood. On the subject of accents, those were the least german sounding Nazi's EVER.
Audra and Laura stole the show, as was to be expected, however I thought the real standout was Ariane Rinehart, who is both beautiful and well sung. Although I did think it was a misstep of the costuming to put Liesl in heels (she was taller than Carrie already).
Overall this was a win for NBC, even if the most prominent commercials outside Walmart were for Disney movies. I hope they tackle other shows in the future.
"Grease," the fourth revival of the season, is the worst show in the history of theater and represents an unparalleled assault on Western civilization and its values. - Michael Reidel