Posted: 9/22/26 at 10:29am
Anybody have any details/guesses for what show Miss Hilty is joining?
Posted: 9/22/26 at 10:31am
I thought I heard she was replacing Simard in SCHMIGADOON!.
Posted: 9/22/26 at 10:38am
EDSOSLO858 said: "I thought I heard she was replacing Simard in SCHMIGADOON!."
This would be hysterical. Both performance-wise and Broadway lore-wise.
Posted: 9/22/26 at 10:47am
Would they pay her enough to jump into WICKED to boost sales?
Posted: 9/22/26 at 10:55am
Posted: 9/22/26 at 10:59am
Posted: 9/22/26 at 11:01am
CoffeeBreak said: "Would they pay her enough to jump into WICKED to boost sales?"
girl lol
Posted: 9/22/26 at 11:05am
BwayMatty327 said: "Could she also be replacing Bowen Yang in Oh Mary after he leaves on 12/6?"
This is what I want, personally. And the notice in the screenshot says she'll be in rehearsal in November, not actually in the show yet, so this would make a lot of sense imo.
Posted: 9/22/26 at 11:16am
BwayMatty327 said: "Could she also be replacing Bowen Yang in Oh Mary after he leaves on 12/6?"
It never even occurred to me that I need this in my life until reading your post.
Posted: 9/22/26 at 11:20am
This would be interesting casting. Hilty followed by Simard as the next two Marys?
Updated On: 9/22/26 at 11:20 AM
Posted: 9/22/26 at 11:22am
Posted: 9/22/26 at 11:29am
Posted: 9/22/26 at 11:30am
She would be amazing as Louise in O,M!
I cannot see her following Simard into Schmig, that would be a little odd…
Posted: 9/22/26 at 11:32am
Interestingly, Reddit says Jafar.
Posted: 9/22/26 at 11:47am
Posted: 9/22/26 at 11:52am
EDSOSLO858 said: "Interestingly, Reddit says Jafar."
You mean... "two joking comments on Reddit said Jafar." C'mon now, you should know better.
Updated On: 9/22/26 at 11:52 AM
Posted: 9/22/26 at 12:12pm
Megan in Rocky Horror makes zero sense.
Megan replacing Simard in Schmigadoon or Sarah Chase is slightly believable.
Megan joining Oh, Mary seems the most likely and best for her talents.
Posted: 9/22/26 at 12:20pm
ACL2006 said: "Megan in Rocky Horror makes zero sense.
Megan replacing Simard in Schmigadoon or Sarah Chase is slightly believable.
Megan joining Oh, Mary seems the most likely and best for her talents."
I don't see how Rocky makes zero sense?
Posted: 9/22/26 at 12:23pm
The only roles for her in this production of Rocky would be Magenta or the Narrator and she's not really right for either.
Updated On: 9/22/26 at 12:23 PM
Posted: 9/22/26 at 12:26pm
Posted: 9/22/26 at 12:38pm
It has to be Schmigadoon - Probably Mildred Layton.
OH MARY seems like a stretch since new casts don’t get a lot of rehearsal time, and Bowen is in the show until 12/6. While they can afford to be risky with casting, I can’t imagine they want to put a new Mary in over the holiday season.
For Rocky Horror, I could see her doing Magenta. I would imagine Sherie’s contract is up when the show was scheduled to close in the end of November. Doing it through February 28th seems like a good gig
Posted: 9/22/26 at 12:42pm
If it is Mildred in Schmigadoon, I don't mean to type-cast, but the original was a former Glinda like herself...Kristin Chenoweth.
It will be like the Elphaba to Elsa pipeline all over again.
Posted: 9/22/26 at 12:46pm
HenryTDobson said: "Does Shoshana have time out at Lost Boys?"
She appears to be out Oct. 16th through the 21st for concerts. She is here in Denver on Oct. 20th.
Posted: 9/22/26 at 12:55pm
How I longed for her Mother in Ragtime, but I’ll take Megan in anything. My gut says Schmigadoon. She could easily replace Simard, but I think she’d be a better replacement for Sara Chase if she’s leaving or taking a break.
Posted: 9/22/26 at 1:16pm
Someone also suggested Audrey in LITTLE SHOP. While that is technically off-Broadway, it makes a hell of a lot more sense than some of the other possibilities.
