Megan Hilty Replacing in Established Broadway Show?

I thought I heard she was replacing Simard in SCHMIGADOON!.

---

Would they pay her enough to jump into WICKED to boost sales?

Could she also be replacing Bowen Yang in Oh Mary after he leaves on 12/6?

BwayMatty327 said: "Could she also be replacing Bowen Yang in Oh Mary after he leaves on 12/6?"

This is what I want, personally. And the notice in the screenshot says she'll be in rehearsal in November, not actually in the show yet, so this would make a lot of sense imo.

This would be interesting casting. Hilty followed by Simard as the next two Marys?

---

Updated On: 9/22/26 at 11:20 AM

I was hoping someone would start this thread! Whatever it is, I just might have to come check it out.

"Rocky Horror" seems to make the most logical sense to me. Do we know how long Sherie Rene Scott is staying?

"Schmigadoon" I have no desire to see this show, buuuuut if Megan Hilty happens to replace, I'll be there.

"Oh, Mary!" Personally, I could also see her as Louise and being so game for it, too.

I can't imagine she'd be going into something like "& Juliet" and her "Wicked" days seems to be behind her. Whatever it is, super excited to have Hilty back. I thought for sure it would be several more years until she returned after departing DBH.

Also, is it professional for the venue to put this information out there like that? I feel like the wording should be something vague like, "conflicting engagement"

Interestingly, Reddit says Jafar.

---