NY, NY may be on its way to closing-NY Post — Page 4

I sent my sister and mother this weekend... texted me at intermission they were bored and didn't understand the plot, but wanted to stay for the title number at the end.

My sister tried googling the plot and said she ended up more confused?

Voter said: "I sent my sister and mother this weekend... texted me at intermission they were bored and didn't understand the plot, but wanted to stay for the title number at the end.

My sister tried googling the plot and said she ended up more confused?"

“A love letter to big city gusto! It has what Broadway lovers want– spectacular stagecraft, a winning score, and infectious optimism.” This opens in a new window. A group of New Yorkers come together to chase their dreams of music, money and love in the new Broadway musical as spectacular as the city itself.”

Respectfully, was this what came up?

songanddanceman2 said: "NotASoundtrack said: "Voter said: "I sent my sister and mother this weekend... texted me at intermission they were bored and didn't understand the plot, but wanted to stay for the title number at the end.

My sister tried googling the plot and said she ended up more confused?"

“A love letter to big city gusto! It has what Broadway lovers want– spectacular stagecraft, a winning score, and infectious optimism.” This opens in a new window.A group of New Yorkers come together to chase their dreams of music, money and lovein the new Broadway musical as spectacular as the city itself.”

Respectfully, was this what came up?"

Do you work for the show, or know somebody on it? I ask because I haven't seen shills go this hard to defend a show in a long time. Let people have other opinions to you."

No, I don’t actually and you inferring that I am (classic) isn’t gonna stop me from sharing my own opinions/pointing out things that aren’t true. I’m just defending a show I think needs/deserves defending because I’ve never seen people pile on a show THIS hard based off of misinformation. And maybe I have, and I only recognize it because I’ve payed close attention to this particular show (as a fan, don’t worry).


It’s also not even just about THIS particular show, but people thinking they can fairly critique a show without seeing and/or running with misinformation just because they read it online and the person said “they know someone”. Disliking a show is one thing, but making up lies is another. (No pun intended)

TLDR: I had time today!

Updated On: 7/18/23 at 06:26 PM

Voter said: "I sent my sister and mother this weekend... texted me at intermission they were bored and didn't understand the plot, but wanted to stay for the title number at the end.

My sister tried googling the plot and said she ended up more confused?"

Honest to god, I don’t know how people cannot follow the plot of this show. If you can follow multiple plots on The Love Boat, you should be able to follow the multiple plots of New York, New York. The story is very simple, actually.

perfectpenguin said: "Idk if the mods are deleting replies again but in response to Matt Rogers post - plots are easy to follow. But the problem is too many. They needed to eliminate one of them."

They could have and should have eliminated that opera singer plot, but even with it included, it’s just a bunch of very simple overlapping stories. I’m no genius but I understood everything that was happening perfectly.


PS - why would the mods be deleting posts?

Updated On: 7/18/23 at 07:25 PM

perfectpenguin said: "Matt Rogers said: "perfectpenguin said: "Idk if the mods are deleting replies again but in response to Matt Rogers post - plots are easy to follow. But the problem is too many. They needed to eliminate one of them."

They could have and should have eliminated that opera singer plot, but even with it included, it’s just a bunch of very simple overlapping stories. I’m no genius but I understood everything that was happening perfectly.


PS - why would the mods be deleting posts?"

Sometimes the mods delete stuff they don’t like! But for this, looks like a glitchy website on my end. I would agree to eliminate the opera singer plot. I didn’t get anything from it. But right, I’m no genius either and followed without issue. My only real issue was the sound. I sat in the balcony and understood maybe 10% of conversation when they were talking to each other. The singing was clear though. "

Oh, I was in front mezz and the sound was totally fine there during previews.

NotASoundtrack said: "Voter said: "I sent my sister and mother this weekend... texted me at intermission they were bored and didn't understand the plot, but wanted to stay for the title number at the end.

My sister tried googling the plot and said she ended up more confused?"

“A love letter to big city gusto! It has what Broadway lovers want– spectacular stagecraft, a winning score, and infectious optimism.” This opens in a new window.A group of New Yorkers come together to chase their dreams of music, money and lovein the new Broadway musical as spectacular as the city itself.”

Respectfully, was this what came up?"

"Respectfully", this is a thematic statement, not a plot synopsis. I was offered comps to this three times. I gave away every single one. The last pair, my mother and sister, hated it, just like the other two pairs I sent. They literally cannot give tickets away. I hope that helps!

Updated On: 7/20/23 at 10:15 AM

bwayphreak234 said: "FWIW - I had no problem following the multiple characters and plot lines when I saw the show in early previews... I just thought that there were too many of them. None of the characters were very well developed or fleshed out IMO. It was just a bunch of surface level vignettes... which maybe that's what they were going for. If so, great. I just didn't find it very effective or engaging. I've already said how I felt about the two leads (which seemed to really strike a nerve and put some folks here on the defensive...), so I won't beat a head horse there.

The whole affair kind of reminded me of Bullets Over Broadway (the other Stroman helmed big budget flop that played the St. James)... Although, admittedly, I had much more fun at Bullets than I did at NY NY."

I enjoyed NY NY more than Bullets, but not a fan of either TBH. What did you think of the leads? I have no clue what you posted and I'd like to know.

Rumors of its death seen to be premature. It's still open........

I just want to be clear, regarding earlier comments in this thread that some people are unfairly dogpiling on this show, that I am not one of them. I went in with low expectations based on the buzz and hoped I'd be mildly entertained or even pleasantly surprised. I wasn't.

So many opportunities were missed. The cast is able and the two leads are good singers, but they're mismatched and given weak, muddled arcs. There's nothing unique about the piece and it plays to the audience so shamelessly with its "New Yaawk!!!!" moments that all I could do was roll my eyes. It literally opened with a prompt to get audiences cheering for nothing. Desperate.

I wish it was better, but it wasn't, and saying people are dogpiling for no reason isn't fair. There are reasons.

Updated On: 7/23/23 at 01:44 AM

Wow! Very abrupt closing even though it was expected…

One week closing notice is rough. They must have had almost no advance sales.

The timing of the press release suggests to me that they had a company meeting after the matinee today and hope to have the news of the closing featured in Monday's papers to hopefully spike attendance in the final week.