I brought family into town to see this and was surprised by how much this disappointed me. And we were all very familiar with Monty Python.
The Good: Michael Urie, Chris Fitzgerald-- both incredible. Ethan Slater? Absolutely nailing it onstage at every turn. Nick Walker was great for Act 1 and you could tell the audience missed his presence more in Act 2. The music of this show is always a great earworm.
The Meh: It was like James Monroe Iglehart was in a different show than everyone around him. Felt disappointed since he was such a fantastic genie... but this fell flat. I like Leslie Kritzer, but there were some moments that really didn't work for me. Taran Killam was... there.
The Bad: The direction... You know it's a problem when two of my non theatre peeps thought the direction was the weakest part. The book is a Monty Python inspired mess, but a good director can make the chaotic sensible. Act 1 felt like a complete mess, where Act 2 felt more like a musical that had been rehearsed. Genuinely, if they had just given all fan service, everything would've felt more coherent. Instead, it felt like it needed another week of rehearsal.
For a bit... we thought maybe we misremembered Spamalot? Nope, we just felt this production was perfectly serviceable. $59 for mid mezzanine was the perfect price.
There are like 3 other people called Voter on here, FYI.
Deleted comment count: 12