So my one-word review of the overall 95 minutes is "pleasant." But man, those 95 minutes drag quite a bit.
It was only the second preview, but I don't think my issues with the show can be resolved during a preview period. The musical elements were worth the price of admission and I think I'd have enjoyed it more just as a concert with a little patter. A better book and crafting of the narrative would give it a bit of the spirit/feel of The Light in the Piazza.
In reading the San Diego reviews, it doesn't seem like they adequately fixed the major problem: the story they are trying to tell through the book and the overall structure of the show. Too many metaphors, too many manufactured plot moments, too many weird interjections of a thought that ends up not being pursued. And the show's opening is too slight and too dull. I really never cared about any of the characters even though I enjoyed the songs they performed.
I spoke with the two people seated in the same row as me and they felt the same about the storytelling and show structure. And if you do not know anything about Daniele's career, some of the dialogue and plot might not make sense.
I would hypothesize the challenges with the storytelling might be the result of Daniele directing her own life story, but maybe other reasons are in play.
All that said, there are about 7-10 laugh out loud moments (albeit some are cliche or stereotypical), the songs are solid, and the performances are uniformly strong although Priscilla Lopez's voice is not. I was in the front row and constantly struggled to hear her. Ironically, there isn't much choreography in the show and the staging is simple with one background through the entire show and a few benches brought on and off during key moments.
The blocking has the cast regularly playing to all sections of the house, including the far sides, so you won't hate it if you end up sitting there. But the center three sections are still what I would recommend.
Generally polite applause at the show's conclusion coupled with some more enthusiastic responses. A standing ovation started slowly and ultimately had 40-50% of the house on their feet by the end.
Oh, and there is a singing deer, one of the "magical realism" components. A sassy and sexualized singing deer who dispenses life advice. His scene/song was actually one of the more entertaining moments.
Updated On: 10/22/23 at 10:42 PM