About the hole Dan seeing Gabe thing. It's just a way to look at it! I always saw that Dan has never seen Gabe before. But starts to loosing it, when Diana leaves him. For me 'I am the one (reprise)' is the first time Dan sees Gabe!
But that's just my interpretation. And that's why I love Next to Normal. And yes it's one of the most thrilling theatre moments!
I've always been thrilled by Javert's suicide in Les Miserables. The bridge pulling out and the turntable washing the body away.
If anyone ever tells you that you put too much Parmesan cheese on your pasta, stop talking to them. You don't need that kind of negativity in your life.
During "One" in A Chorus Line when Zach asks Cassie "Is this what you want?" (apologies, don't know the exact line) as the dancers sing in the background.
When the whole orchestra takes over from the piano during the opening in A Chorus Line
"Tomorrow Belongs To Me" from Cabaret. Haunting.
I also gasped during Priscilla when the curtain rose after "I Love The Nightlife" to reveal the bus has been spray painted.
Glad JERUSALEM and McDonagh have been getting love in here. Great moments from both, I co-sign whole-heartedly.
In terms of thrilling, honestly, one of my favorite audience reactions was the audible gasp heard when I saw REASONS TO BE PRETTY when Sadoski told Piper Perabo to go home. I personally felt like it wasn't just watching man grow up before your eyes, it was watching a playwright mature right in front of me too. Neat moment, that.
It's hardly a twist or anything of that sort, but "thrilling" it was indeed: pretty much the entirety of Geoffrey Rush's performance in EXIT THE KING. A truly titanic and all-consuming achievement. Utterly spellbinding.
Words don't deserve that kind of malarkey. They're innocent, neutral, precise, standing for this, describing that, meaning the other, so if you look after them you can build bridges across incomprehension and chaos. But when they get their corners knocked off, they're no good anymore…I don't think writers are sacred, but words are. They deserve respect. If you get the right ones in the right order, you can nudge the world a little.
EVITA "disappearing" from her death bed in the revival. Stunning effect IMO. MATILDAs "School Song" number, and the lazer effect right before Revolting Children. WICKED - a strange moment to comment about, but when Fiyero is carried off on the pole and silhouetted to look just like the Scarecrow.
For Younger Brother. Zach and Cassie are downstage, near the peak of their argument, as the chorus upstage goes through their routine mechanically and quietly. Cassie has just said something that hurts Zach deeply.
Cassie: "I'm sorry - I had no right to judge." [pause] "Why are we doing this? I mean, we must be over this by now, aren't we?"
Chorus, quietly: "One smile an suddenly nobody else will do"
Zach: "I am" [he really isn't]
Chorus, almost silently: "You know you'll never be lonely with you know who"
Cassie: "Then don't feel you owe me any favors. Just treat me like every body else".
Zach, losing it: "Is that really what you want from me? "[points to line] "Is this what you really want to do?"
They turn up stage to watch as the line comes to life, singing full-throated, music building, lights up:
Chorus : "One moment in her presence, and you can forget the rest, for the girl is second best to none, son. Oh, sigh - give her your attention. Do I really have to mention, she's...the...one! [stands still and shouts] "ONE! ONE! ONE! ONE! " [whispers and crosses upstage as the lights fade on them] "One. One. One One".
At the very end of the 1st act of Grey Gardens. After Ebersole finishes singing Will You out to the audience/party guests on the lawn, the floor beneath her suddenly pulls her away from us upstage. The future, decrepit house front closes, cutting her off from us almost as if the house is swallowing her.
One Last Kiss from Follies. All anyone ever needs to see to understand the entire show.
Sunday from Sunday in the Park. Reduces me to blubbering tears, every time, no matter how many times I see it and no matter how much I don't expect to cry again. And I can't for the life of me explain why. The words are benign enough. Maybe it's the shear beauty of the music and the closure of the moment. I know squillians of people who are affected in the same way. So it's not just me.
Art has a double face, of expression and illusion.
A few recent moments On and Off-Broadway-- not exactly twists, but thrilling moments for me:
The finale of THE SCOTTSBORO BOYS (I won't give it away, since it seems to be playing the provinces as of late)
Michael Cerveris as the "bad" brother in ROAD SHOW doing a softshoe upstage, while his mother sings of his charms despite his absence to the "good" brother, Alex Gemignani
Jane Alexander's last lines and exit at the end of THE LADY FROM DUBUQUE
Certain moments in the last revival of RAGTIME really impressed me, but for some reason I'm stuck with the staging of "New Music" and the Emma Goldman number
Linda Lavin's reading of "A little girl down the hall died, but I got a box of Jordan almonds!" in THE LYONS-- Hysterical laughter, and then the audience (me included) thinking, "Wait, we laughed at that?"
Jan Maxwell's "Could I Leave You?" and ESPECIALLY Danny Burstein's "The Right Girl" in the recent FOLLIES
Nearly all of the last ...VIRGINIA WOOLF? revival, because it was such a refreshing take on the play. I think when the audience realized that George was the one in control (rather than Martha, as usual) may have been the moment that got me. One of his first scenes with Nick maybe?
You're welcome, Younger Brother. It's a very well-structured scene. The ending always killed me, the kick line, all in warm, golden light, that changed slowly to a cold, almost unnatural light and faded to blackout as they continue to kick into eternity.
Clifford's return causing Myra's heart attack in Death Trap.
The Act I curtain of the New National Theatre of Tokyo's Pacific Overtures when the American flag unfurled all the way from the back of the house to the stage at Avery Fisher Hall and enveloped the audience.
The end of JERUSALEM, for sure. Rooster's dance with Phaedra to "Who Knows Where The Time Goes" is such a beautiful, heart-stopping moment, and then everything through the end was just shocking. It had the same effect on me the second time, too. Mark Rylance was phenomenal in that role.
I remember gasping the first time I saw the HAIR revival when Claude says "I'm right here" and we see him, for the first time, without his hair. "Like it or not, they got me." It's chilling even when you know it's coming.
The choices made by Amy Morton and Tracy Letts in the WAoVW revival were oftentimes shocking. Letts was ravenous and I felt that I never knew how to react to him or his choices. It kept me on my feet, exploring such well-known material with new choices and new perspectives. They were both incredible and provided a thrilling, devastating evening at the theatre.
When Dorothy Collins stood on state with that beautiful grey dress singing "Losing My Mind", a revelation! Bernadette wasn't as bad as people say, but "LMM" was the highlight of her performance - she brought the crazy, Dorothy brought the longing!
- The Lion King - The Circle of Life...amazing opening number. Mufasa's mask scene also gives me chills every time. - Pippin (2013 revival) - Magic to Do and the Finale - War Horse - When foal Joey becomes adult Joey - Marie Antoinette at the A.R.T. (Cambridge, MA, 2012) - To mark the start of the French Revolution, there's a huge crash, the windows of the palace break, and a ton of dirt falls onto the stage. Really striking and surprising. - Next to Normal - I walked into this show knowing nothing about it, and was shocked when I learned about Gabe. - Sweeney Todd - Beggar woman reveal - Grace - I thought the opening scene with the homicides/suicide in reverse was well done
Christine Ebersole's "Another Winter in a Summer Town" and the moments of Mary Louise Wilson screaming for her to come back before you know whether or not she actually does. Also, the window framing her face at the end of both acts.
The last twenty minutes of Wit. Certainly not a twist, but gut-wrenching all the same.
Kristine Nielsen's phone call in the second act of Vanya and Sonia
Dan and Gabe at the end of Next to Normal.
The beauty of the wedding sequence and the final moments of the recent Last Five Years revival.
The Act I finale of Ragtime.
Sutton Foster's dazzling "I Get A Kick Out of You" at the top of Anything Goes and the Act I finale.
The sequence in War Horse near the end of Act I when the general is blown off of his horse by a grenade and "flies" offstage.
Paul's monologue in A Chorus Line
"I Am What I Am" in La Cage
The latter half of the second act of The Normal Heart, beginning with Emma's monologue
For arts and culture commentary, along with other assorted opinions, visit WEEPING ON WHEELS at http://weepingonwheels.tumblr.com/
Mary Poppins' flight at the end of Act II The pigtail illusion in Matilda Sam's "fading in and out" entrance in Ghost The mirror display of the Swastika dance in Springtime for Hitler in The Producers The beginning... middle... end of An Inspector Calls The last 20 minutes of any production of Sweeney Todd The first 6 minutes of any production of Sweeney Todd Realising in Merrily we Roll Along, what we saw was all from Charley's mind
and, I'll end with a moment in an RSC production of A Christmas Carol that I saw in 1994, when the ghost of the Christmas yet to come was 35 feet high and was a piece of automated scenery, essentially. It glided across the stage and at one point his arm stretched out over the audience. One of the most amazing pieces of design ever!
Nick Hutson
Co-Presenter/Producer
MusicalTalk - The UK's Musical Theatre Podcast
http://www.musicaltalk.co.uk
Absolutely those final 15 minutes of JERUSALEM. Really the final act made me sob (both times I saw it) from the slow dance through the end of the play, but the end was unbelievable.
**Spoilers**
When he's pounding on the drum and all of a sudden you can hear the wind and start to see the trees move. Then the distant rumbling getting louder and louder and then a black out... Just the ambiguity of whether it was the demolition trucks or he summoned the giants. I had chills!
"All the world's a stage,
And all the men and women merely players:
They have their exits and their entrances;
And one man in his time plays many parts..."
~Jaques - "As You Like It" Act 2, scene 7
*One that stuck with me: In John Doyle's Revival of Sweeney Todd, Tobias delivering his final monologue as he is being guided back into a straight jacket....and then, as he is gagged, you realize that the gag is the muffler Mrs. Lovett was knitting him. I remember thinking "They don't even need the final ballad. Bring the curtain down right here."
*One that struck me recently: The Moment the curtain rose in act two of Peter and the Starcatcher, and after an hour spent in a dark, claustrophobic set it was suddenly a vast opening field of translucent blue.
*One that will always stick with me: I doubt many here saw it, but the final moments of the San Francisco Opera's Ring Cycle in 2011, directed by Francisca Zambello. In this production, the rheingold (which is stolen in the first opera to be forged into a magic ring) was a giant gold cloth the Rhinemaidens played with, billowing up and running under it like a game of parachute. After the gold is stolen and turned into a ring, the next time we see the Rhinemaidens is three operas and nearly a week of opera-going later, and in Zambello's production, they were seen wading through their river, now full of plastic bottles, their white dresses turned black with grime. So almost at the very end, when they retrieve their gold, and one of them came rushing downstage with that gold cloth and thrust it aloft, you bet your sweet bippy that I cried like a child.
-"Angry Dance" from Billy Elliot. -"The Story of the Escapologist and the Acrobat" from Matilda. -The first five to ten minutes of Tarzan with the massive storm. -Cinderella's dress transformations in the current Broadway production. -The war sequence in Dogfight. -The progrom in Fiddler On the Roof.
"Anybody that goes to the theater, I think we’re all misfits, so we ended up on stage or in the audience.” --- Patti LuPone.
Always thought the knife dance scene in Martin Guerre where the villagers murder each other was pretty breathtaking. My personal favourite is from a long time back 1986 Chess with Tommy Korberg in Endgame - his performance sent shivers down yours spine and the whole scene was beautifully staged.