jlindsey865 said: "Rentaholic2 said: "NOWaWarning said: "I’m a little surprised Schwartz has allowed so much riffing."
I’ve heard riffing / optioning up in One Short Day, Popular, Wizard and I, Dancing Through Life, and Defying Gravity, just from the trailers and clips. It’s a little much. Is Doctor Dillamond gonna turn Something Bad into an American Idol audition? That’s my one criticism so far, but everything else looks amazing."
This is an example of criticism I find difficult to understand. Of course, everyone is entitled to their opinion, but I completely disagree with this one. Every vocal choice I've heard so far has felt intentional and tasteful. Have you listened to what many of the Elphabas have done in the Broadway show? It's far more dramatic than what Cynthia is doing. Granted, I haven't heard the full soundtrack yet, but I find this particular critique quite puzzling."
Maybe more of a minor personal quibble than a real criticism. They all sound great from what I've heard. I've just noticed that every song we've heard so far has at least one riff that isn't in the score, and it just makes it all sound a bit poppier (and sometimes indulgent) than I want out of a musical theater score. Like, is One Short Day really enhanced by a riff?