I was at the invited dress and did not want to post my thoughts until after this weekend. I definitely enjoyed the show. There is some great stuff going onstage at the Brooks Atkinson. That being said, I did not love this show as much as I thought I would. The cast is truly stellar without a weak link. Jessie Mueller is great. Just like Beautiful, I think that Waitress suffers from not the greatest book (although I will say that the book for Waitress is much superior to the book for Beautiful IMO). And, just like Beautiful, Jessie Mueller manages to hide some of the book's weaknesses with her phenomenal performance.
The three women are all great and deliver the goods. Christopher Fitzgerald is also great, even though I thought his number came off as a bit "stalkerish...". The score for this is very good for the most part. I am a Sara Bareilles fan, and I was not disappointed. The ballads and romantic duets are definitely when the score is at its very best. There were a few songs that didn't quite "work" for me, but overall, I was impressed with the score.
The choreography for this show is strange, and at times unnecessary. It reminded me a bit of the choreography from If/Then. Lots of movement, but not exactly dancing, for no real reason. That could just be me though. I thought the choreography during the pregnancy scene was pretty strange.
The set was very effective for the most part. I loved the proscenium of rotating pies and the onstage orchestra. I also loved how Jenna's apartment was the only closed off portion of the set. It really created a sense of isolation.
Overall, I definitely had a good time at this show, but I can't say it's something that I would say to rush to see right away. In fact, my mom and her friends are coming into town in a few weeks, and I planned on taking them to this since it seemed like such a great "girls night out show", but I am actually exploring other options. Jessie Mueller is incredible, and her "She Used To Be Mine" is out of this world. So in the end, I guess I would say that I "liked" this show just fine, but I was by no means blown away.
"There’s nothing quite like the power and the passion of Broadway music. "