I saw Hamilton in Chicago on my birthday (woo!) a few weeks ago, but had no idea where the stagedoor was (and was crying too much to be coherent anyway). My friend saw Hamilton earlier this week, and we were meeting for dinner so I grabbed my Playbill from home and ended up meeting her at the theater and going to the stage door to take the chance to tell the cast how much I appreciated them etc (I'm not really an autograph person).
Anyway, the thing is, I saw it with Joseph Morales, and Miguel Cervantez was playing Hamilton that afternoon. Turns out, I am a terrible liar!!! He came out and when he got to me I 100% froze. Internally I was like "You can't say anything! You didn't see him!" He looked at me and after a way longer pause then should have ever existed kindly asked "Did you enjoy it?" To which I responded: "I cried the whole time!" (which is true of the performance from two weeks ago haha). He said, "That's what makes it good, right?"
I know how absolutely trivial it is because they meet so many people, but I was mortified and felt so bad for literally days after so I went ahead and bought one of the released lottery tickets from tonight. Met him again, it was lovely, got to tell him how lovely his voice is.
Side note: I told Jonathan Kirkland I thought his voice was very beautiful and he thanked me and said many people don't like it, but that's okay, which was super sad :/