I caught the show on Friday night and it was a mixed bag for me. Like a lot of people, I kind of grew up with the movie, catching it on TV for it's network television debut (remember those?!) at a very young age.
I hate to say it because I usually like her work, but Megan Hilty was the weak link for me. She plays everything with an exaggerated, affected manner and I think it undercuts a lot of her (pretty solid) material. I wish she'd let the mask drop a little, ground herself more and lean into some of Madeline's nastiness and misery in a real way. For me, that would have made her funnier. On the whole, I think the show could have afforded to be a bit more cynical. "Finding your person" is a lovely sentiment, but maybe not here?
Simard finds a better balance between groundedness and being over-the-top, but her character has a clearer arc. Sieber is reliable, as always. Michelle Williams, weirdly enough, gets the show's best songs.
I was really not a fan of
Click Here To Toggle Spoiler Content
Helen being the one who kills Madeline and then the handling of how Madeline kills Helen. Helen's presence throughout the staircase bit and hospital adds nothing, really, but to water down Christopher Sieber's material. It's also much more interesting to me if Madeline kills Helen before she realizes she's taken the potion thinking she'll actually die. Another example of where the show eschews darkness.
The effects are also hit or miss. Madeline on the staircase is a triumph, but other things feel like afterthoughts. The score is fine, I agree with others that it may not stand on it's own but it works in context.
I didn't have a bad time, I enjoyed a lot of about it, but it feels so close to almost there that it's more frustrating than if it had been an all out misfire.