EDSOSLO858 said: "I’m glad the Tony committee recognized that although Ramin is a fabulous singer and shows great emotion in his singing voice, he cannot act his way out of a paper bag when speaking.
This has been the case for a long time."
Disclaimer: Big Ramin fan here, so take it how you will. The only show I can think of where he had lines and singing was Anastasia and I thought he was quite good. Phantom and Les Miz (Tony Nominees) were more operatic in structure and his acting was great in all 3 (including Love Never Dies - Olivier Nominee). He did Holby City for 2 years and his acting was amazing - comic, tragic, romantic. Granted his voice is his primary talent and what a talent that is.
The problem with this show is the leading lady and all other issues stem from that. To act, it's nice to have something to REact to. Beanie's acting skills (I've never seen her in anything else) appear to be film related, which is completely different from stage acting. Even so, there was no there there. I have never seen Ramin perform with anyone (male or female) where he didn't have some sort of chemistry. So, I think he did a great job taking Nicky along his path.
When I heard he was going to do this show, I thought he would be a great Nicky. He was offered the role almost 3 years and I wonder who was considered for Fanny back in 2019. I would love to see him with Julie Benko in this venue. I heard boots of the three main songs and her singing and acting were fantastic.
Different leading lady, different result.
Bottom line, however, there would have been no Funny Girl without Beanie. Anyway you look at it she is responsible for the production. Only wish someone might have had the sense and courage and/or good grace when realizing the boat wasn't going to float to replace her - that includes Beanie, herself. If that sounds mean, I'm sorry. This seems to be the general consensus, so I don't think I'm too out of line.
Not sure how long or how many of her fans will continue to support her. Some people may want to see the show because there are some high points and it's a fun piece more in line with Music Man than Company. Still, there are a lot of other shows people will want to spend their money on.
Updated On: 5/9/22 at 08:12 PM