Okay, I didn't write a review after I saw the show a few weeks ago, both because most of my thoughts had been covered by others and I was hoping they would make changes. But since it sounds like they haven't made changes, and there's one aspect that hasn't been mentioned enough...:
I'd never seen a fully staged production of Gypsy, though I'm familiar with the material. I thought it was...fine. It was competent. It was also lifeless. It played like a museum piece, an adequate presentation that gives a respectable idea of the show without justifying its existence or demonstrating why this is supposed to be the greatest musical. There was a moment during "Everything's Coming Up..." when Audra was working furiously, and I was kind of getting into it just watching her, but then I glanced over at Burstein standing in place with no discernible expression, and Woods standing there with her shoulders slumped and curved inward, a blank, glazed look on her face like she'd gone numb, neither of them really reacting to what Audra was doing, and I thought that was the production in a nutshell. Nothing was connecting, even among the performers onstage. The fact that that huge stage was so sparsely decorated, forcing Audra to work harder to generate energy on that big empty stage, didn't help. But then the sets often felt too small for the stage. (The "Rose" sign in "Rose's Turn" was pathetically small and one of the saddest things I've ever seen. I'm sure some will argue there was a point to it, like a Black woman in this time period would know that there's a limit to her dreams so she can't imagine anything larger than that even in a fantasy, but it just seemed part of how small everything felt.)
The only signs of life in the show, IMO, came from Brittney Johnson in the very minor role of Agnes/Amanda. When she came onstage, I was immediately like, "Oh. Who's that?" I learned afterward she was Glinda in Wicked a few years back, and I wish I had seen her now. It's such a small part, but I hope she gets some notices in the reviews. Every time she was onstage it seemed like she was making the most of the least, and while everyone else was dutifully going through the paces, she actually seemed like a living, breathing person, with joy and energy and life. I wanted more of her and hope to see her in a better production of something in the future.
Updated On: 12/16/24 at 05:21 PM