The issues with the Strip sequence aren't based in the actor, they're based in the changes made to the structure of the number. There are four "Performances" in the strip - the first time Gypsy goes onstage in Witchita, the Philadelphia Strip where she is growing in confidence, the Detroit strip, where her stage persona is more polished, and then the Minsky's strip, where she is a fully-formed star. (I think the city names changed a bit from production to production?) Each of these has a monologue and a bit of singing attached to it and we watch Louise's act evolve from nervous stammers to flawlessly-delivered stand-up comedy. Wolfe changes this. He puts the monologue from the Minsky's section into the Detroit section and climaxes the strip with a Josephine Baker dance number. And we are told, repeatedly, that Louise cannot sing and cannot dance. That she has no talent. that's the whole point of her arc, that she finds a talent that's not the ones that her mother values. If she can dance the whole time, she has talent, and it makes no sense! No knock on Joy Woods, necessarily, and since I saw the show on the first preview, when the quick changes were still not fully worked out in their timings (I imagine this has improved). I'm not sure if this choice was driven by Wolfe's conception or by wanting to show off Joy Woods' skills as a dancer (which she absolutely has) but in either case it's not a great call. It's the one scene where I was really let down by Wolfe's concept, which I generally liked quite a lot, and it seriously affected my opinion on the production.