Jarethan said: "Ftworthguy said: "I was lucky enough to see this production. While I realize some people (no pun intended) had issue with Audra's vocal performance, she was one of the great actors to play Rose -- it was absolutely transcendent. And I loved her in the role so much"
I saw Angela Lansbury, Tyne Daly, Linda Lavin, Bernadette Peters, Julia Murney (Cape Playhouse), Audra MacDonald and, on film, Bette Midler and Rosalind Russell, many of them multiple times. I did not see Patti Lupone because I was 'all Gypsy'd out' at the time and had limited slots available in one of my trips to NYC while it was open.
Of them all, the only one who I felt was wrong in the role was Audra. I didn't really have a problem with throat voice vs. chest voice at all. She has a great voice for the ages and who says that the songs can't be sung a little differently from everyone else.I did have a problem with Rose's Turn. I felt that her vocal inflections were just 'too black' for a character who never would have been black in the real world.
I've been reading your posts on here long enough to give you the benefit of the doubt, but there's probably a better way to word this, brother. And for future reference, the term is "head voice" not "throat voice." No snark intended, I appreciate your reviews etc.