bwayphreak234 said: " While the representation and themes in the show are great, that does not immediately equate an inherently good show or give the show a free pass from being critically analyzed."
I think it's also a question of representation of what? I've seen both the documentary and musical and didn't think the musical did a great job representing the challenges and personalities of the three young women who were the center of the doc.
For example, in the documentary, for the most part, people in the program weren't able to ask each other out, without the therapist taking them both aside and basically feeding them lines. Having the kids in the musical able to ask each other out unsupervised, I thought minimized what a huge hurdle the dance represented to the group.
Also in the musical, I thought the kids were more upbeat compared to the doc, where many of the people were considerably more frustrated, argumentative and less empathetic because of issues reading other people.
I'm not saying people with autism can't be cute and cuddly, I have a two-year-old daughter with autism who is exactly that. However, I wasn't recognizing the individuals profiled in the documentary in the tone of the musical.