Really surprised that many, including Jesse Green in the Times, find such fault with the ending. To me, like the entire play, act 5 is a seamless and deftly staged marvel of construction. The moments of agreement and disagreement between Nathan, Rosa and Leo were to me riveting.
One of the standouts in the flawless cast is Arty Froushan as Fritz in act 2 and, unrecognizably, as Leo in act 5. His moments of recovered Kristallnacht memory revivified by a broken cup, cat's cradle, and a chair in the exact same position with Uranowitz's adjacent Nathan as they were in act 3 (then Uranowitz as Ludwig) is perhaps the most, dare I say, Proustian recognition I have ever seen on stage. Uranowitz and Augen are also in every respect brilliant.
I dissent from Green's view that the last act is an authorial self-indictment of Leo. Instead I see three people whose experiences during the war and Shoah were extremely different; whose lives have been extremely different. I see those accidents of history. And I see love amid devastation.
***
While it is nearly impossible to keep exact track of every character (indeed the characters themselves are baffled by who's who), Stoppard miraculously in each act highlights the relationships at the center of the next one, e.g., Hermann, Gretl, Hannah and the not yet seen Fritz are clearly identified in Act 1 before they become the act 2 drama; while the political zest that define Nellie's relationship with Aaron in act 3 leads wonderfully into the precipice that Nellie and her son Leo find with Percy in act 4; in counterpoint, Hermine's flirtations with Otto in act 3 lead, again, through a related sacrifice, to her alone in act 3 with her son Hiney (whose fate is the final recitation of act 5). Each act is extremely different but each vital to the whole.
Updated On: 11/23/22 at 02:46 PM