Several of us have parsed the story on the OT board -- and having any reservations about this feel good film of bad feelings generator, 2016, isn't terribly popular. I get why: it's an exercise in style, start to finish, built on a wisp of a plot, if any. The movie has no subplot, no counterpoint notes, not even a supporting player (Legend does little, but pull Gosling away). So you are pretty much held hostage to these two for 128 minutes, their ups and downs are very small potatoes, very odd obstacle-driven. You go with that, or you might find holes.
SPOILER
The bone of contention for some of us is the dinner scene wherein Gosling cooks for Stone, and what goes down. I was blind-sided by it on the big screen, and then revisited it on my screener. What irritates Mia -- this man's willingness to tour a couple of years to make some needed bucks (he can't pay his bills in the opening introduction) -- is simply impossible to swallow. All of this "follow your dream" integrity stuff from a woman who 30 minutes earlier in the story has a breakdown because she loses at TV pilot for a show that's described as recycled garbage. Suddenly, prepping a one-woman show for a 99 seat theater in LA (yeah, that's a usual venue for discovery, right? Ask anyone who's worked in LA theater) makes her the serious artist, but he's a sell-out for wanting to tour with -- wait for it -- John Legend. Who is supposed to be beneath Gosling's dream because he doesn't play jazz. It's ludicrous, but the actors play the scene so well -- they give it everything they got -- it reads as having an emotional logic. Why this guy who plays Christmas carols in a restaurant til he's fired can't tour a while and pocket some needed bucks upsets her is a mystery. She works in a coffee shop. And then Gosling basically forces her to get her big break in a major studio film because she gives up her dream (which earlier was just, you know a JOB acting, anywhere, anytime -- until she throws in the towel.). Still, they must split. Nothing about this has the whiff of reality, if they are in fact soulmates.
END OF SPOILER
But the movie doesn't really ride the reality of struggling artists. It's a fantasy. If you look too closely at any of it -- I have friends who get the giggles when they see Stone in her 99 seater, earnestly setting out to tell some story -- it falls apart. I can smile and enjoy most of the musical sequences anyway.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling
Updated On: 12/27/16 at 05:19 PM