My two cents:
The word of mouth I've been hearing is that the plan is for THE HUNCHBACK OF NOTRE DAME to indeed end up in the Nederlander eventually (that's if they stick with the intimate concept and it proves to be successful). However, I'm still skeptical as to how this time-table will work out for them given the current circumstances.
First regarding NEWSIES, I think the closure has more to do with the national tour at the moment than HUNCHBACK, though I would say the two are somewhat related. NEWSIES is still making a nice profit just about every week, therefore the Nederlanders can't evict them so this had to come from Disney. My guess is that they have noticed the show was more than likely going to lose most of its steam within the next year (and replace it with Hunchback), especially with a tour on the road (as bringing fans to NY was a HUGE part of its market), and have decided to save money and use the Broadway set as opposed to building an entirely new one and scrapping the Bway one in a year. Selling the Broadway production to out of town tourists will no doubt become more difficult when it is competing with a National Tour.
Think about it: the Bway production closes August 24th and the Tour begins tech in Schenectady in early September. That is the perfect timetable to ship that set out. I'd be willing to say a majority of the cast may even go with it. It would explain why there is still no announcement regarding tour casting.
Regarding the timetable for HUNCHBACK, the plan was La Jolla in Fall 2014 and Paper Mill in Spring 2015. They may be planning to either forgo the Paper Mill engagement and go straight to Broadway from La Jolla if possible instead of trying out the same show with the same cast and design twice in the span of 6 months, or (depending on the Tony Eligibility date) they could open on the very last day of the season. While neither of those options seem particularly viable or practical, the last thing I could think of is that the Nederlander might undergo some much needed refurbishment that could take up to 6 or so months and that would make it more likely to still be open for a late summer/early fall 2015 HUNCHBACK opening.
Sorry guys, I've just been thinking a lot trying to justify why this show is actually closing so suddenly. It seems to have taken most everyone by surprise, cast included.
Updated On: 6/23/14 at 01:15 AM