Sadly, Amy Sedaris has said no already as she thinks she can't handle the role.
I originally read this as Urie playing Mary post-Jinkx, which would be a hoot as well
I was hoping to see Michael Urie play the role of Mary but excited to see him as Mary’s Teacher.
As others mentioned, I agree that the show has the potential to run for years. After Jinx Monsoon, does anyone think that Cole might return?
Stand-by Joined: 5/30/19
I believe there were reports at their final show that Cole was done playing Mary in NY.
Hannah Solow on yet again tonight.
Since members keep track of other performer’s attendance - Tituss has now missed eight performances (equivalent of a full performance week) of his six-week return to the show.
GiantsInTheSky2 said: "Hannah Solow on yet again tonight.
Sincememberskeep track of other performer’sattendance - Tituss has now missed eight performances (equivalent of a full performance week) of his six-week return to the show."
Seeing it today for Tituss. Hopefully if they cancel we know prior to heading to the theatre.
GiantsInTheSky2 said: "Hannah Solow on yet again tonight.
Sincememberskeep track of other performer’sattendance - Tituss has now missed eight performances (equivalent of a full performance week) of his six-week return to the show."
Kudos to Hannah for going on so much recently after barely going on for the first year with Cole and Betty. Someone else mentioned that Jackie Sanders is back as a vacation swing. I wonder if they'd have her go on once of Tituss calls out again.
Huss417 said: "Seeing it today for Tituss. Hopefully if they cancel we know prior to heading to the theatre."
If the show is still adamant about not giving any refunds or exchanges for cast absences, then I’d doubt they make any kind of announcement other than a playbill insert
Jordan Catalano said: "Huss417 said: "Seeing it today for Tituss. Hopefully if they cancel we know prior to heading to the theatre."
If the show is still adamant about not giving any refunds or exchanges for cast absences, then I’d doubt they make any kind of announcement other than a playbill insert
"
I won’t be scanning my ticket till I know for sure today.
Some people have gotten both refunds/exchanges. It seems who you end up speaking with be it Telecharge or the box office. If it comes to that today I will be talking to both until they do something.
The price of what they are charging is crazy for it to be a crapshoot. I’ve seen the show with Cole and will be seeing it with Jinkx so they will at least see the history on my account.
That being said fingers crossed that Tituss is there.
Huss417 said: "Jordan Catalano said: "Huss417 said: "Seeing it today for Tituss. Hopefully if they cancel we know prior to heading to the theatre."
If the show is still adamant about not giving any refunds or exchanges for cast absences, then I’d doubt they make any kind of announcement other than a playbill insert
"
I won’t be scanning my ticket till I know for sure today.
Some people have gotten both refunds/exchanges. It seems who you end up speaking with be it Telecharge or the box office. If it comes to that today I will be talking to both until they do something.
The price of what they are charging is crazy for it to be a crapshoot. I’ve seen the show with Cole and will be seeing it with Jinkx so they will at least see the history on my account.
That being said fingers crossed that Tituss is there."
According to the box office, Tituss is currently scheduled to do both shows today.
ACL2006 said: "Huss417 said: "Jordan Catalano said: "Huss417 said: "Seeing it today for Tituss. Hopefully if they cancel we know prior to heading to the theatre."
If the show is still adamant about not giving any refunds or exchanges for cast absences, then I’d doubt they make any kind of announcement other than a playbill insert
"
I won’t be scanning my ticket till I know for sure today.
Some people have gotten both refunds/exchanges. It seems who you end up speaking with be it Telecharge or the box office. If it comes to that today I will be talking to both until they do something.
The price of what they are charging is crazy for it to be a crapshoot. I’ve seen the show with Cole and will be seeing it with Jinkx so they will at least see the history on my account.
That being said fingers crossed that Tituss is there."
According to the box office, Tituss is currently scheduled to do both shows today."
He was also scheduled to be in the show last night. He is scheduled to be in the show 8 times a week. What the box office said is correct until something can happen later in the day.
Has Jinkx missed a performance in Pirates? I don't think she has, and I think her attendance was to be pretty good in Chicago and Little Shop. Am I misremembering?
ChairinMain said: "Has Jinkx missed a performance in Pirates? I don't think she has, and I think her attendance was to be pretty good in Chicago and Little Shop. Am I misremembering?"
I don't know about PIRATES, but Jinkx never missed a show in CHICAGO. Jinkx does have two scheduled absences in Oh, Mary!
There are no discount codes out there for Jinkx's run, right? I was hoping we might see some when Jinkx joins the cast, given how overexposed she's been on the New York stage of late, but that seems unsure now that Kumail is also joining the cast.
Updated On: 7/20/25 at 03:54 PM
Tituss is out of both shows today.
Hopefully producers remember his attendance record next time he wants to do Broadway “on his terms”.
Stand-by Joined: 6/10/09
Saw the show with Titus last week - was SENSATIONAL! Raven Symone as Mary Todd would slay
GiantsInTheSky2 said: "Hopefully producers remember his attendance record next time he wants to do Broadway “on his terms”."
Yeah. If I counted the understudy page correctly, he has missed 16 performances out of 48 - essentially 1 in 3. It would look different in context if he was doing a six-month run, but it’s a very bad look for a six-week run.
I’m THRILLED for Hannah because she is able to get the exposure she deserves. I just wish people would not direct their frustration at her just because Tituss didn’t show up to perform.
I’m going to Jinkx’s first show on Monday so I’ll be excited to see how the mostly new dynamic plays out.
It's officially Monsoon season at the Lyceum!
Looking forward to hearing reports from tonight, Quizking101.
EDSOSLO858 said: "It's officially Monsoon season at the Lyceum!
Looking forward to hearing reports from tonight, Quizking101."
Their rush was a zoo this morning.
I have "kid going to Disneyland" levels of excitement about seeing her in this.
Going next Monday and cannot wait.
Videos