I'll bite and post my thoughts about tonight. I'm writing this for personal reference as much as anything else, so I apologize in advance for any rambling.
Tonight was amazing. From the moment I walked in there was a really high excitement level and I could tell that everyone really, really wanted to be there and that was really cool. I must have seen a good 10 people dressed as Hedwig.
When Tits of Clay and RNJ walked on at the start there was thunderous applause. When Yitzhak said "Ladies and Gentlemen" everyone stood up and we didn't sit back down until after TEAR ME DOWN. It was loud, everyone was sinning along and it was just perfect. There was a good two minutes of applause afterwards.
The show went on with some random bursts of clapping and a lot of laughing. By the time we got to SUGAR DADDY everyone was up again. When it got to the carwash JCM actually had to push someone down into their seat so he could carwash them. Needless to say, there was a lot of applause after that as well.
The absolute highlight of the night though was ANGRY INCH. JCM crowd-surfed. He made his way into the audience and made it about halfway through the orchestra then back. It was once again a sing-a-long and so incredible.
Speaking of sing-a-long, during WIAB, JCM just said "You know what to do" instead of telling us to sing along. I know i’m beginning to sound like a broken record, but the crowd was really into that as well.
Skipping ahead to Midnight Radio, over lots of improv and funny moments from JCM, when JCM sand “hold on to each other” the whole theatre held the hands of the people next to them and the whole entire theatre swayed in unison. It was one of, if not the coolest moment I have ever had in a theatre.
After the show, Stephen Trask came on stage and played piano while JCM sang Lou Reed’s Satellite of Love.”
Overall, tonight was everything I wanted it to be and so, so much more.
P.S Rebecca Naomi Jones did a great job!
P.P.S Darren Criss was there
P.P.P.S Matthew Broderick and Sarah Jessica Parker were there too, and SJP looked really uncomfortable the whole time